In reply to Mark Kemball:
https://cdn.ukc2.com/i/351831.jpg
Hi Mark. I was looking at the other routes you describe while I was there yesterday, and reckon they follow the lines in the above photo, they are a couple of meters to either side of the line I climbed and do not share any holds, it was also not hvs.
I will be surprised if it has not been climbed before but I cannot find any record of this independent line being done.
Litchen does not seem to grow on all areas of rock on the ridge whether it sees regular climbing activity or not, it may also depend on the angle and orientation of the walls
I think this is worty of investigating further as Tom agreed it was a great route