In reply to grit-addict:
Hmm... I just wrote:
"You're presuming that they *are* trying to turn it into a mainstream sport area, no? Plus it says Josie's routes are new routes, not rebolted ones. And this has been done to death already, so maybe you're just stirring
If you're not, your concerns may be valid, and we all have some, but maybe this is not the place for it? This is about a 10 year old FA-ing a 6a+."
Then looked up The Sidings in my book. The article says it's a new slate sector, but it's in my slate book. Not only that, but the slate route currently highest on my wishlist, "Above The Line" is on there, so I thought "please tell me that's not been bolted!"
So I looked up in the wiki. Above The Line (the only original listed route, others are only vaguely mentioned) is still down as HVS 4c, and all the bolted routes look to be new.
I almost deleted this whole post as it might kick of a discussion rather than prevent it, but I'll leave it up instead and run away!