In reply to johnr2:
> Me? I don't climb anymore, too old and with a hip replacement. I remember the days when the British were right up there on the international scene. The Brits don't seem to do those new big hard routes anymore. Maybe I'm wrong, but the really hard stuff seems to be getting done by the Swiss, French, Spanish and Russians. I never said the CM was easy, but it's a long long way from the cutting edge.
As far as mountaineering goes, “cutting edge” is not a fixed, well defined quantity (like “hardest” or “most difficult”). You must have a reference point – “cutting edge” or “hardest” in comparison to what? Right now the real competition is on the Andes and Himalaya, but there are several routes opened more than 20 years ago in the Mt. Blanc area that have still a fearsome/fierce reputation, and are infrequently repeated by talented climbed (maybe not famous, but talented still), or in few cases, are still awaiting their second ascent. Few names: Frenesye Pascale and the Hypergoulotte on the south face of Mt. Blanc, Directe de L’Amitie, Gousseault, Groucho Marx, Phantom Direct or Ypercouloir on the Grandes Jorasses, Coracrazion on the NF of the Greuvetta (a scary route if ever was one), or relatively venerable stuff like the Lesueur line on the NF of the Drus (first climbed in 1958!). Even the Bonatti-Gobbi at the Grand Pilier D’Angle (a route that was not technically extreme even when it was first opened in 1957) is still considered “something”
All these routes maybe are not exactly “cutting edge” if you consider the single climbing moves, but if you can repeat them in fast, good style, you definitely belong to a gifted minority.