In reply to Mick Ryan - UKClimbing.com:
Hi Mick,
Is there a change of policy then? I can no longer find the link to any of the Grand Day Out articles already published.
If so it's a pity. Part of the joy of these comps is reading all the contributions, not just the highly polished, professionally written ones that deservedly win. Everyone has to start somewhere and everyone needs encouragement.
People shouldn't underestimate the courage it takes to hit that submit button, nor the buzz you get seeing your work out there for everyone to read.
As to it being fair or not, I'm not sure how reading earlier entries is going to help somebody win. It's not a quiz and they're unlikely to copy the answers. Writing is a personal thing, requiring ideas as well as technique. As long as the judges don't take into account the, (sometimes partisan), critiques of the forum, I can't see the problem.