In reply to Mick Ryan - Senior Editor - UKC:
Howdee Mick - us revert to old school grades? Whatever next.... high top climbing shoes??! I'd rather give people something to think about really and if it's the wrong grade, it's the wrong grade. Life goes on. I think it's a shame James P didn't grade his recent escapade on grit, because of grading issues - a bit of slagging of never hurt anyone (too) much
In reply to others:
You always get criticised for overgrading but people never mention the undergrades - it's a one way flow. When Andi T graded Thumbalina E7, he got a load of slack for that, but at least he actually suggested something. He also suggested a grade which I think is pretty much in line with general softness in the Churnet, a brave move, but a sensible one as I also try and grade my routes in line with the area, rather than my own local stomping ground.
Another thing to factor in, is that for me (Pete may not agree) I grade routes with the hope that some of my mates might try those routes in good style. Thus I don't go for sandbagging dangerous routes, just for being cool for sandbagging - more with the idea of what I'd say to a mate if I were being genuinely honest about my appraisal of a route. Pete's E8 could be E7, but to me it's in line with other E8s like Angel Share, Ultimate Sculpture, Marbellous, Superbloc, Power of the Dark Side and That's My Lot. Yes, some of those are now highballs and the such - I guess it's just personal style of what you like doing and how you like grading! Mostly it's just about going and having some fun and pushing yourself.
I know people will be really interested in debating all this stuff as it's all good pub talk, but to ask either Pete or I to give some huge answer or detailed breakdown, it's just not going to happen as we just want to go climbing and not focus on all the grade debate - too depressing!! As for hyping a route grade for publicity - well, E8 and E7 aren't exactly cutting edge now are they? If both our routes come down to E7 and E6 (or both E5s....) then, that's cool - at least someone's been excited and motivated enough to go and repeat them.