In reply to Dane1:
As an engineer what are your thoughts on the pick hardness and the angle of the pick point?
I found the ice shattered and stuck more when trying to extract with the Nomics compared to the Quarks.
I couldn't understand why as the picks are the same, until I noticed the upper chiselled part of the pick was wearing faster than the actual point!!!
It was only when I placed them both side by side with a straight edge (between the pick and the handle) that I noticed the the Nonic's pick point didn't strike the ice first, hence the strange wear....
I know you probably know this but others wont!!
My thoughts are, that on typical classic ice routes in Scotland there's often lots of easy ground with steep corniced exits, where a more traditional ice tool has it's merits.
The runners and belays are not normally insitu, so a lot of clearing and cutting with the adze is necessary to find the gear placements.
Often the cracks are blocked with ice or verglass and so a hammer for placing gear and pitons is essential.
On steep snow with no rock or ice belays, you need to be able to construct snow anchors, such as buried axes or bollards using an adze. You also need to be able to cut through cornices, if there's no alternative.
With steep snow approaches and descents, I'm far happier and safer with an axe I can effectively self belay with, or if I get caught out in a storm, an axe I can dig an emergency shelter with!
On roadside dry tooling and on continental style steep ice routes with instu belays, I'm sure the Nomic has it's merits. For longer alpine style routes with long snowy approaches and descents, I'm still sticking to the Quarks unless someone can convince me otherwise!!!
I've climbed Point Five first with classic curved axes and then later found it far easier with MT Vertages. More recently I've climbed it with old style Quarks which made it even easier! However I'd still hesitate to use my Nomic's on the route without swapping the hammer and adze from my Quarks. I'd also miss the ability to plunge into hard neve and to clear slots for threads...
Cheers Ron