In reply to oscaig:
Ditto what's been said above.
I've climbed at Butter Hole; it was ok as long as you're happy with the chossy top-outs and the place-your-own-stakes belay method (I haven't been there for a few years so I'm not certain this hasn't changed, but I've not heard of any stakes being put in so expect to have to do this yourself).
I would climb there again if I was passing but there are more venues in the area that I would visit first.
I've always thought the CC Guide is a bit stingy with stars in this area too, but if you read though the route descriptions it's usually possible to pick out some fantastic routes without worrying too much over stars.
Have a good time.