In reply to Stuart Hurworth:
> (In reply to victim of mathematics)
>
> Fair enough.
>
> I would say that it does include some independent climbing but it is only a few metres worth and although good it isn't the highlight of the route. However there are other routes around with little or no additional climbing, alternative starts or simply linking up of two good pitches on different climbs.
Like I said, I'm going with the guidebook writers on this one. If you can persuade them that it warrants a separate entry, then I'll add it to the database. Isn't the independent climbing basically a couple of metres of walking along a ledge (assuming you've taken the right-hand variation on Christmas Curry, which I think most people doing the Micah Eliminate do)?
>
> I have no experience of The Plum but I would certainly say that the route we went is better than the Micah Finish - which is excellent in itself but surely the best part is the exposed arête finish, which this route includes and I would say improves upon with the difficult move?
This may be true, although your combination is rather unbalanced in terms of difficulty, and does miss some really nice sustained 4a climbing on the section of the Micah Eliminate that you eliminated (for want of a better word).
I guess the main point is that if you're capable of the moves on The Plum below where the Micah Eliminate joins the arete, then you really ought to get on The Plum itself, which is brilliant, and fairly low in the grade with the start as described in the latest guide.
>
> Do you not think it is worth including the route under whatever name simply because many people climb it? (it's probably a very popular route!)
I've never seen anybody on it. A fair few people might do it by accident, or back off it when the realise they must have gone wrong somewhere, but I can't imagine anybody (or almost nobody) would actively set out to climb the combination you did if it were in the guide. Which is why I don't think it warrants an entry. And imagine the potential for traffic jams with people taking 3 independent routes to the top 10m of the arete!
>
> At least I put a description unlike some of the other offerings!! What is Treemudrock or Finish of Moments for example?!
Both are described in the definitive guide. UKC is hardly a substitute for that, and I'm not inclined to spend hours of my life either stealing the CC's route descriptions wholesale, or making up my own for no tangible reward. Be my guest if you want to add some descriptions yourself though...
By the way, in case you're wondering, the Treemudrock Finish is both hard and a bit pants. I haven't done the Finish Of Moments.