In reply to Allan McDonald (Gwydyr MC):
> (In reply to Richard White) The fact that he mentions a 'Socialist' totaliterian state is a ruse, I dont care whether its a socialist or tory totaliterian state either is wrong and to be honest we are more into a tory one than a socialist one.
The totalitarian states his dystopias were based on were the Nazi and Marxist states, which were certainly as brutal and absolutist as anybody could imagine (or wish for). We certainly do not have a totalitarian state in Britain, to say so is ridiculous hyperbole. 1984 was very much of a piece with Arthur Koestler's Darkness at Noon, and several other dystopic novels of the time, though as others have rightly said, 1984 was neither a prediction nor an instruction manual, but a warning, as all good dystopias are. The author of course does not want his "predictions" to come true, that is the point of writing the book. Animal Farm was a bit different as it was allegorical history of the Soviet revolution.
Clearly this professor is simply trying to make a name for himself by being controversial for the sake of it, and not very intelligently so either. But I had forgotten just how good some of Orwell's essays are till this thread and another one recently provoked me into re-reading a couple of them. His extreme lucidity and ability to cut through bullshit and to speak plainly but eloquently and to the point is invaluable.