In reply to Jon Stewart:
> I think you've hit the nail there. Although there are now more climbers, that increase is made up of a lot of people who climb indoors and progress to bouldering and sport climbing outdoors. These people don't own guidebooks to Gable and Pillar, they don't look at the routes and long for a hot spell in the summer when they might come into condition.
Whilst I value your opinion, that is really just opinion.
> If it's true that the crags are less popular now than decades ago
I've been climbing since the mid eighties, mountain routes were just as green and chossy then, many will be no matter how many people do them.
> I assume that when these crags were popular it was when climbing say E3 on a mountain crag meant you were pretty good, it was something to be quite proud of. The routes might have more kudos, they might not have been done thousands of times. I think the status of these crags might have changed hugely in people's minds. These days, if you're on Gable Crag you're eccentric, but if you're on Raven Tor you're the man.
If you were free climbing on Raven Tor in the eighties, you were the man.
I just don't see much of a disparity between when I started and now (well, 2012, which is when I left the UK). In fact I did a route on Pillar in 2011, but I had to switch because there were two parties already on it. Is that significant? Probably not. None of these empirical type observations are meaningful unless we stand at the bottom with a clipboard for 20 years.