In reply to Removed Usergilesf:
> I couldn't comment on the BMC guide but I'd struggle to imagine it being significantly better than the Rockfax one.
Different beasts. The BMC produce the definitive guides with all the routes, all the boulders, all the history, little features along the way, etc. A series of volumes covering everything in the Peak - a must-have collection for the local or obsessive/nerd. Rockfax on the other hand produce very user-friendly, practical guides. For the Peak. Over and over again.