In reply to MrRiley:
> Yeah the ratio of actual ice to snow is very good and if you caught that third pitch in nick too it would be stonking!
Seven years since I did it (
http://www.petestack.com/blog/the-white-line.html ), but my conclusion at the time was 'guessing that this third icefall simply doesn't form so readily'. (NB Mike Pescod's photo linked from my blog is no longer there, but seems that's what folk here are effectively saying too.) As for my 'slight whiff of possible sandbag at III in the conditions we found it in', I think I'd just say I thought it was IV now!