In reply to Thesingingphotographer:
Thanks very much for your suggestions so far.
I had considered doing the route in reverse next time. I think the only thing that makes me hesitant is that it makes most sense to climb Skiddaw in the night time. Unless dawn has arrived before the road section has finished, I feel we'd have to climb Helvellyn in the dark, too. Borrowdale is suitably long to allow dawn to arrive before reaching the next mountain section. Using the old railway route is a good suggestion for it in either direction.
Thanks for the clarification regarding Ordnance Survey maps and green lines. I guess my lack of recent walking has made me assume from past experience that green lines tend to be associated with reasonable paths. I have now since learned otherwise! I don't mind pathless terrain if it's in good condition. I now know that Eskdale isn't a particularly viable alternative to the descent of Lords Rake. It wasn't a lack is Explorer Maps that I meant to flag up- more the green dotted lines marked on it. My wording wasn't massively clear.
Our experience of Wythburn was less favourable in that it was virtually pathless and boggy up to the point of being more than knee deep in oily swamp water. Not great when we'd covered over thirty miles and been walking for eighteen hours!
I do however much appreciate the alternative route via Steel Fell. It may be a knee wrecker but we've (so far) got good knees. It was the feet and dehydration that were kicking in. Also the use of satellite technology to look at the paths is a great idea. Thanks!
Is there anyone else out there who has actually done the walk? It's a beast but we managed 35 miles and three of the four peaks. I really feel that we can do it next time with more benign conditions. Up to Scafell, we thoroughly recommend the 3000 challenge for hardcore walkers. Skiddaw was memorable, as was the early morning ascent of Scafell Pike...
Cheers
Mike