In reply to TheFasting:
> So it's more like a bragging rights thing?
:0)
No it's about doing the same sport. If the sport is different than a correct choice of venue applies. It is not alright to play golf on a bowling green. They use grass and balls but not in the same way!
Dry-tooling is an accepted sport and should be practiced in dry-tooling crags. All the rest is semantics (was it white...) or non-arguments except when it comes to turf damages (it scratches/ or not). Turf damage is an issue ecologically but that is NOT why most people get annoyed (like me). The issue is that once the turf is gone the route may be either significantly harder (one move wonder) or impossible (completely blank). I stated above I am no ecologist (if I were I would stop travelling places to climb) but I know that turf forms at an astonishingly slow rate (mm per century or some such).
However, you can always brag when you were successful on a route due to really thick rime when everyone else use this as an excuse to bail