In reply to Offwidth:
Except I went back and finished it later (with enough aid that I didn't bother logging it). And I'd also done most of the 2nd pitch on a top rope after abbing from above. And the comment was based on what I was told. And wasn't meant in a negative way at all, it was meant in a "please visit the crag and climb the route" way. Other than that your reply is fair
Quality is down to personal opinions, especially on such a rarely visited crag. But I stick by my assessment that it is one of the best routes I've done anywhere. We'll only get a consensus on grade (which might be HVS) and quality (which I think is 3 stars, you think is 2, but could easily be 1 or 0 for all I know) if enough others visit.
PS It gets hollow/green stars which indicate it may need a clean (though it didn't when I climbed it, other than removing some vegetation from the niche on p2)
PPS It's much better than Greensleeves which got 3 stars in the previous edition, and better than The Sizzle which has 2 stars (and did in the previous edition) and is verging on 3 (a bit short for that)
PPPS Most of my visits were in the Winter, as were most of the first ascents