In reply to TobyA:
> UKC Rob has raved about some of the Scarpa models in reviews in recent years, including for on grit, but I'm so confused by the number of high end models from Scarpa I can't remember which ones he recommended for what.
Don't worry Toby, neither can I 😂
> I'm currently trying out the Scarpa new midrange models the Quantix and the Quantic - both seem good but I need to use them more to decide what the differences are between two superficially very similar shoes. The Quantix is the softer of the two, the Quantic more edgy.
I haven't used the Quantic or Quantix, but they do sound like they'd fit the bill for what the OP describes.
The Vapour V is the other that springs to mind. I didn't think it was up to much as far as edging was concerned, but if it's a Grit shoe you're after then that isn't a problem, and the fact it's soft will likely be a benefit. That said, it wasn't a shoe that I fell in love with, and certainly wasn't one I continued to use for very long after the review had been written; however, it has - rather curiously - been a much better seller than its predecessor, so make what you will of that...
Following on from that theme, whilst it may not be Scarpa's most successful model, the Instinct SR has been my Gritstone shoe of choice for a fair few years now - both for trad and for bouldering. These have very recently been superseded by the fantastic - and much improved - Instinct Slipper (review incoming...), although these are perhaps a little more oriented towards bouldering, being a bit more technical and a little less supportive. Slippers are definitely a more specialist choice, and aren't for everyone, but I've just found these to fit really well, providing a level of comfort, support and precision that's seen me through everything from the casual evening solo to some of the hardest boulder problems I've ever done. It really is a pleasure to climb in them...
Obvioulsy plenty of other brands, and other options out there, but that's a quick assessment of a few the Scarpa shoes I've reviewed within relatively recent history - seeing as the question was asked.
Post edited at 16:26