In reply to Gordon Stainforth:
> (In reply to old skool)
> [...]
>
> It's arguably the most outstanding achievement, ever, in terms of consecutive high altitude ascents.
Oh FFS, Gordon, calm down. They are one of several teams to do Everest and Lhotse this year, and have added Nuptse. Kenton is an excellent and experienced alpinist and no doubt his mate is very strong too, so adding one more peak to what the guided clients and 'guides' have done is not exactly 'historical'.
For something to have historical context it must be compared to what went previously and as Nuptse has not been fixed like this in concert with the other two then the logistical conditions have not previously existed so comparisons are illogical. Well done to Kenton and Dorje Gyalgen for taking the unprecedented opportunity to do all these three ascents in a row, but it can't be compared to much else.
As above, all three routes are fixed, thanks to an army of Sherpas and tonnes of bottled oxygen. These ascents bear little resemblance to climbing just ONE of these peaks without any of that aid. Fixed ropes and a beaten path make high altitude climbing immeasurably easier - yes, easier - which I and others on here know from experience, if it wasn't obvious enough.
Comparisons with other climbs on other mountains in other years are ridiculous and insulting to those who went before. From high on G1 I've looked across to G2 and simply could not believe how Messner and Kammerlander could have the sheer f#@king audacity, let alone fitness and skill, to launch off down that unknown, unfixed, untrodden, un-camped ridge to the other, without fixed descents, or set-up camp rests in between.
This is UKClimbing, not UKCool.