In reply to Jack Geldard - Editor - UKC:
The article is interesting, as are the responses. I speak for my team, but not necessarily every individual within it. We are a varied bunch, young middle aged and knocking on a bit, male and female, left and right wing, atheist and god fearing; in other words, people. We enjoy rescuing people but obviously wouldn't wish ill on anyone. We have support mechanisms in place when something nasty is witnesses. We have a massive file full of appreciative letters from casualties, many with donations. We rescue relatively few numpties, and when we do, we have plenty of time to make them aware of the error of their ways. We rescue both experienced and inexperienced. We share a joke with some, we console others. I am hugely proud of what we do, and the positive reactions we generate.
Should mountain rescuers be paid? I believe not. Should mountain rescue receive Government funding?..maybe, but with no strings.
At present each team has developed methods of working that suits its area and clientele. In Cumbria we enjoy a good relationship with the other emergency services, although I am aware that this isn't necessarily the case everywhere. We assist in non MR jobs when the weather is poor. How could we sit there with a garage full of 4WD and know that someone is suffering because a conventional ambulance can't reach them through the snow or flood water.
We have a dozen swiftw*ter rescue technicians. A useful skill on the hill as well as the riverbank.
Some of my most rewarding moments have been in dealing with the relatives of the deceased. So are some of my grimmest memories. I love being part of a team.
We have no funding crisis, no recruitment crisis. We are 'media savvy'. It would be negligent not to be!
We are little different from the Sunday League football coach, the staff in your local Oxfam shop, or Guide leaders. We give because we can. We are part of the great tradition in this country of volunteering. Our families are happy (mostly!) for us to be involved. My boss is happy..he's been rescued in Scotland and sees the value of what we do.
There is national MR fundraising, as has been pointed out. There is a national MR body. Locally and nationally MR is in a state of constant flux. It evolves and changes as the world changes. As long as it rescues people to satifactory standard, leave it be. We lead the way in the world in many ways. Our casualty care is of the highest standard. We are amatuers, in the truest sense of the word. (Translated from its French origin to the English "lover of", the term "amateur" reflects a voluntary motivation to work as a result of personal passion for a particular activity (wikipedia)). That may seem sentimental, but it the only sound reason to be involved. If a team member loses sight of this, it's time to move on and fill your life with something else.
Because it isn't driven by profit or shareholders, it doesn't need to be governed by anyone else. We can manage without Health & Safety legislation because when it comes to it, we all want to go home to our families. There will be no cost saving short-cuts.
If anyone needs a reminder of the effect MR can have, please have a look at this link
http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2008/nov/22/family
On final note, I have to disagree with the comments about suicide. It is not a selfish act, it is the act of a very desperate person, driven by forces well beyond their control. They are victims, not at fault.
Have fun in the hills. May we never meet in my team capacity!
Nick Owen, Team Leader, Langdale/Ambleside Mountain Rescue Team.