In reply to Jack Geldard - Editor - UKC:
A sort of serious question - not a troll anyway.
On the blog I just skimmed they are talking about climbing up to M5. At what point does this type of climbing stop being 'free'? What's the difference between pulling on a bit of gear wedged in crack, and pulling an axe with a the pick firmed torqued in said crack?
Normally, I wouldn't give a flying fig about such things - its alpinism, right? Anything goes. But with all the hyperbole about this being a 'free' ascent it makes me wonder.