In reply to Saor Alba:
> (In reply to Jamie Bankhead)
>
> You are right. Many people are now convincing themselves that routes are in condition by using get out clauses such as "early season conditions", "marginal" etc.
>
That is not his point. His point is that the "What's in Condition," page on UKC which lists every winter route logged by someone on UKC is suggesting to others where they should climb. If the first person made a bad call, then they have just opened the floodgates for others, maybe those with less experience to judge correctly (or don't care as long as they get their buzz,) to go after the same route and it will lose all it's turf.
> The hundreds of blogs, all the same - climb now, climb yesterday, climb tomorrow, climb on the computer etc - are now being feed with a desire to out blog every one and being seen to be climbing for a self-recognition reason.
As regards the "hundreds of blogs," that you mention; what you think motivates people to write them and what actually motivates the individual to write them are two different things.