Forever on the Mountain by James M. Tabor

Forever on the Mountain by James M. Tabor, 12 kbFOREVER ON THE MOUNTAIN: The Truth Behind One of Mountaineering's Most Controversial and Mysterious Disasters, by James M. Tabor.

Published by WW Norton New York, July 2007. (

Hardcover: ISBN 978-0-393-06174-1; 6" x 9"; 400 pages; Sports/Adventure

Winner, 2007 National Outdoor Book Award for History/Biography.

Winner, 2007 Banff Mountain Festival Book Awards Grand Prize Shortlisted for the 2007 Boardman Tasker Award.

Author's website:

Midnight ambience in the Alaska Range, the twin summits of Mount Hunter prominent to the left of centre, from Denali.
In 1967 twelve mountaineers set out to climb North America's biggest mountain, Mount McKinley or, as it's now known, Denali. Seven of the climbers were trapped near the summit in one of the worst storms ever to hit the mountain. With winds of 150mph and the wind chill dropping off the bottom of the scale the storm raged for ten days, at the end of which, despite a belated rescue attempt, all seven climbers lost their lives. In a gripping read James Tabor painstakingly reconstructs the story of this ill-fated expedition and attempts to recreate the most likely scenario which led to the men's deaths in what remains America's worst mountaineering disaster.

From the very beginning the expedition had problems when the National Park Service insisted that a permit would only be given if teams were deemed to be sufficiently large to carry the necessary provisions up the mountain. And so two quite disparate teams consisting of three mountaineers led by Howard Snyder were given no option but to join a team of nine led by Joe Wilcox, a young mountaineer with considerable experience. Wilcox was elected the overall leader and the expedition set out in June 1967. Undoubtedly Wilcox and Snyder did not see eye to eye and Wilcox's problems only increased when he crossed swords with Brad Washburn, one of the most widely respected pioneers of climbing on Denali.

Through extensive interviews with survivors and access to many of the original documents, Tabor brings alive the progress of the expedition which in those days was little short of Himalayan proportions. A total of 38 miles from the ranger camp to the summit with more than 18,000 feet of ascent gives some impression of the vast scale of this mountain. Apart from some help with mules at the beginning of the walk-in the twelve men had to make numerous repeat carries between camps in order to establish the seven camps in preparation for the summit attempt. Even today, with teams being flown in to an altitude of 7,000 feet, the average climb still takes three weeks.

After several weeks Joe Wilcox and the Snyder team got to the summit then descended to camp seven to give the remaining climbers their chance. It's likely that they got to the top but as no bodies or diaries were ever found Tabor speculates as to what befell the stricken party when the worst storm in living memory hit the mountain.

Back down at the National Park Station a junior ranger, Wayne Merry, tried repeatedly to galvanise his superiors into initiating a rescue but it was only when the storm abated after ten days that the National Park Service belatedly initiated a rescue attempt. Merry, who was on the first ascent of Yosemites El Cap's Nose route went on to become chief ranger at Olympic and Mount McKinley National Parks, and is a respected authority in Search and Rescue.

Tabor courageously shows, through his forensic analysis of contemporary documents, how the authorities banded together to protect themselves from criticism by laying much of the blame for the disaster on Wilcox's shoulders. He comes to the conclusion that although Wilcox made some mistakes he was not ultimately to blame for the disaster. The duration and severity of the storm was unprecedented and it is doubtful that anyone could have survived.

Much of the interest of the book lies in Tabor's interviews with the survivors, all of whom became high achievers in their respective fields. Intriguingly Tabor even managed to interview the 94 year old Brad Washburn shortly before his death in 2007.

Although this is James Tabor's first book he is a regular contributor to outdoor publications in America and writer and executive producer for a TV series on caving and the great outdoors. His meticulous research on a subject close to his heart gives pace to book which is never slowed down by references to his extensive source material.

Even if Denali is not on your wish list, this book is a thoroughly rewarding read, giving fresh insights into one of the most controversial accidents in recent American climbing history.

Read an interview with James Tabor, including questions such as "If there's a Forever On The Mountain movie, who should play Joe and Howard? " at

Pete Monk, 9 kbThe reviewer, Pete Monk lives in Clitheroe, Lancashire and started climbing and caving in the early sixties and has memories of a mispent youth at Wallend Barn in Langdale. He still gets out on the crags but his interests lie mainly in hillwalking in Scotland, the Lakes and the Dales. He still gets to the Alps every summer and is currently completing all the three thousand metre summits in the Pyrenees. He is an avid collecter of mountaineering and caving literature and a keen amateur photographer.

This review has been read 10,706 times