Guest Editorial - Motivations? by Nick Bullockby Nick Bullock May/2008
This article has been read 5,480 times
© Naomi Klien
Experiences, adventure, passion and love are vital and a sense of belonging is vital. To me that means climbing, but to the wider audience climbing is not important. Our climbing pond is small, like a goldfish bag carried home from the fair – on occasion big-fish egos swell against the plastic.
I consider my climbing as personal and at the top of my ability, certainly not cutting edge. However, in the past, on occasion, my upward motion had me thinking I was better than others. I am glad to say that, with age and understanding, these feelings have relented. Unfortunately some of our 'top-climbers' in Britain do not appear to have grown up as much as they could have. It seems that to them 'image' is most important, even more important than the act of climbing itself.
Life is about lessons and climbing should be about adventures that enlighten us - at whatever level. There are those who struggle up VDiff's at Birchen who actually climb far harder, and far more at the edge of their own personal boundaries than many slick E-grade leaders. As a collective we should support each other. Climbers performing at the cutting edge should be climbing first for the adventure and love of the activity, and secondly to inspire and encourage, and never to intimidate others. Forget the profile, the sponsorship deal and the ego - or at least forget it when touching the rock or kicking into the ice. We should be sponsored so that we can climb, not so that we can boast!
Logo-splattered, sterile and posed pictures in magazines are becoming frequent. They offend me - more and more I find myself questioning motives. Should this matter that much? After all we live in a consumer society. Well, to me it matters a great deal: Gorgeous set-up poses are glamorising and belittling an activity and culture that I hold higher than most other things, an activity that at its core, is dependent on going to the core of yourself and getting away from the shiny surfaces of our sell & buy world.
The internet is an amazing source of information. But I have started to wonder what is motivating what - blog to inspire, or climb to blog? If you are up there climbing with the best, appearing in the magazines, climbing new routes at the top grades, be honest with yourself when you submit the report. That really hard practised climb you beat into submission - yes, a fine physical achievement, but did you persevere for adventure or was it for upward motion of another type?
Am I just envious? Maybe a twinge, because I know if the climbs on the blogs, in the magazines and on the internet are actually climbed for the sheer joy of being out there, for the push to the limit, for finding liberation, for screaming f*ck-off to a cotton-wool society, then yes, I'm definitely envious of the emotions, and the experience.
Scottish winter climbing is about adventure - but for how long? Top-roping and pre-inspection is now acceptable when technical limits are pushed, but will this lead to people using the same tactics on climbs of a lower grade? And why shouldn't they? There are examples to be set, these examples will be followed. Winter climbing in Britain should be hard, cold, uncomfortable and beautiful: Shafts of light cutting through clouds, searing hot-aches, shimmering lochs seen from a distant summit, shivering on a belay stance in clouds of spindrift - an unforgettable experience. Winter climbing in Britain should be the domain of people who understand this, it should not be for people who need a glamorous article to turn the Ben in to a fashion show. Elitist? Possibly, but we will read less about rescues and accidents when more of us go out into the hills expecting a fight. Climbing always has been, and in my opinion, should always remain a diverse activity for the minority.
"British climbers will fall behind in standards if we don't have the really hard technical bolted climbs of abroad or we only climb on-sight..." Who cares? British climbing's long-standing world-wide reputation is based on adventure for adventure's sake.
We all climb for different reasons, but there are now some reasons for climbing that are suspect. I feel it's time to take stock and slow down. Let's just celebrate inspirational and remarkable at whatever standard. Let's just reduce the glamorising and the dressing-up. Take Everest - as far as I'm concerned Everest is lost - we should cut it loose so it can float away on its ship of media-madness. Let us cling to what we have left before it's too late.
Alpinism is the dirty relative of Scottish winter climbing, there are not so many nice shots here, and Super-Alpinism is actually disgustingly messy. No slick set-up-images to be had (hardly worth doing then?). To be involved with Super-Alpinisim the climber has to be prepared to get weak, throw up, get the shits, fight red-tape, bribe officials, spend months away from the gym and be out of contact with everyone. Relationships at home fall apart, your bank account haemorrhages and it takes months to regain the grade you rock climbed at a year before. But succeed or fail, you will have gained more. You will have yak bells ringing in your memory. You will have the early morning wood-smoke hazing the view of the churning river in the valley below. You will have a memory and experience that will last for life.
© Nick Bullock
Nick is a climber's climber. Willing to stick his neck out in more ways than one, he has written passionately about a topic that he holds dear to his heart; climbing. Nick is himself sponsored by various companies - the equipment they provide him with means he can climb often, work less and drink more red wine. In return those companies get to associate themselves with a crazy, mountain-mad lunatic who pushes all aspects of his life to the limit. He's sponsored so he can climb, he doesn't climb so he can be sponsored.
His book of essays is due to be published soon and it is a work of fire-fuelled honesty - watch this space.
Read Nick's other UKC articles:
- Echoes by Nick Bullock
- TENTATION. III/6 - Point Lachenal
- Chamonix Alpine Report 2006
- Alpine Reminiscence 2007
Share this article on Facebook
Share this article on Twitter