/ PRODUCT NEWS: New Wild Country Blaze, Boost and Flare harnesses in store
Read more at http://www.ukclimbing.com/gear/news.php?id=5464
On every harness I've tried recently you end up with a stupid and annoying 25cm+ length of strap at both waist and legs thanks to the ziplock style buckles which by necessity require much longer straps. In every case the designers have proved utterly incapable of coming up with a decent way to tidy the straps away in use. [Edelrid deserve an honourable mention for their innovative new waist buckle/strap design, but it still doesn't work at the limits of adjustment.]
The new WC harness range have nice pretty colours EXCEPT they have very clearly joined the club and bollocksed it up by not designing a good way to stow the annoying long straps that result from the choice of ziplock buckles.
I am perpetually disappointed that supposedly competent manufacturer are utterly incapable of designing harnesses that are still usable at the lower end of their advertised size ranges...
> I am perpetually disappointed that supposedly competent manufacturer are utterly incapable of designing harnesses that are still usable at the lower end of their advertised size ranges...
Hear-Hear,as an ageing climber I dont have an "off the shelf" shape,basically I am a fat git with thin legs and find it impossible to find a harness that fits me.
The LAST thing I want on a harness is a speed-undo buckle, especially one described as "slick".
First, that means the straps need to be long enough that the harness can still be put on over the hips easily by someone at the larger end of the size range. It is definitely the case that more spare strap is needed for than than compared with a traditional harness where the waist belt is wrapped directly around the waist. If the manufacturers aren't reasonable generous then they lose the purported advantage of the harness being quicker to put on. Therefore, in all harnesses at the lower end of the size range the straps are excessive.
Second, the straps on ziplock type buckles have doubled back ends. If you cut the straps without replacing these, the buckles would undo pretty much every time the harness was taken off. Since the buckles aren't designed for this, re-threading them is much more awkward then normal buckles. As such, the harness would be a pain to use and you would have the worry about the possibility of loops completely undoing.
As such, if someone did want to alter a WC harness they would really need to visit a cobblers to get the straps professionally shortened with new bar-tacked ends. If that doesn't constitute a design failure, I don't know what does.
I think I would put it at worst in my vaguely annoying list, you seem to be surprisingly annoyed by it. I much prefer zip-lock buckles so can live with a bit of extra strap. On my Renegade I don't remember it being a problem at all, it reaches the vaguely annoying on my Arcteryx harness. First world problems eh? ;)
That is similar too my problems. I'm just plain skinny but I still find that leg loops never adjust small enough. However, because I am tall and thin I can't drop down in size to an XS, if available, as the the rise height is then too small.
Various harnesses 'almost' fit but they all end up with long straps flapping around uselessly.
I just can't believe that companies that supposedly employ highly paid specialist design teams can't sort out such simple issues with their products.
They do?! I had presumed a couple of blokes in Llanberis or Tideswell sketched out what they'd really like a harness to look like and then sent it off to China or Czech to have some samples made up. ;)
> employ highly paid specialist design teams
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA. Thats one of the more ridiculous things ive heard on here. Highly paid? What on earth are you on about? As an ex engineer you'd know that engineering is not well paid for what you do unless you're in upper management, and companies like this aren't exactly flushed with cash.
I am on the very small side of a medium which means a long tail and I have always found that the two threadback holders mean no problems.
If you have time to try one please do and please send your feedback once you have tried one.
Elsewhere on the site
Pete Whittaker has flashed the 32 pitch route Freerider 5.12d on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley over three days,... Read more
Last year, Finn McCann wrote an article about climbing El Capitan with his terminally ill father Seamus, who had been... Read more
A fantastically versatile little pack; whether out running in the hills, hitting the trails on the bike or just running for the... Read more
Manchester Climbing Centre is showing Reel Rock’s Valley Uprising on Tuesday the 11th of November at... Read more