In reply to MG:
Here is my issue:
"Management of the deer population through stalking is essential"
Yes that is correct.
"The cull maintains the health of the deer stock..." No this is untrue. Many, most, deer in Scotland are in a poor state due to poor feeding, a population above the carrying capacity of the land and very little shelter. Deer taken from Scotland were bred in NZ and showed an increase in size quite quickly.
".,,,and prevents environmental damage through overgrazing."
This is so far from the truth that it either displays a total lack of realism or a total disregard for others' opinions.
Much of the Highlands is an ecological slum with low biodiversity, very few trees, massive over grazing and high run off due to poor soils. Sporting estates promote this by
maintaining high deer numbers through winter feeding and never culling enough. This way they always have a reason to cull as there are always too many.
Even the slightest common sense and traveling around the Highlands shows that trees grow where deer can't get to such as islands and fenced exclosures. The rest is a barren wasteland.
"Stalking and venison production are the main source of employment and income for this local Highland community."
There are no communities in many of these areas. In the case of Glen Dessary or Glen Pean there are no schools, shops, houses, services, plots to build a house and so on due to the strangle hold that these estates hold on the land and anyone wanting to use it.
They are bad for communities, the environment, the economy and life in general. Stalking is not the problem. Management which maintains high deer numbers and total control over the economy is the problem.