In reply to james may:
> (In reply to Martin W) The quote is taken from RAB's quality assurance statement on their garment tags
Ah right, I thought you had got it from the web somewhere. (In fact ScraggyGoat's posting suggested that was the case.)
> which is just one of several statements that that are intended to influence a potential purchaser into choosing to buy their products.
True, but it isn't actually a warranty. If you read it carefully, it's a statement of why they think their stuff is as good as they know how to make it, which isn't at all the same thing. Also, at the end it says: "...we are convinced that you will get a lifetime of enjoyment from
our products." Note: not "this product". I wouldn't be at all surprised if this wording was chosen very specifically!
> The garmants still look reasonably good so I was surprised that they were not prepared to repair the pockets and the trouser zip which only needed to be stitched back into place at the lower end.
>
> The key issue is that although the fabric still looks good, it is no longer waterproof
Which could be used to argue that the garment was worn out ie it had reached the end of its life, so the zips weren't worth repairing.
> and that poses the question of how it compares to other comparable materials and whether or not the marketing messaging is over hyped.
Over-hyped marketing is one thing, failing to fulfil the terms of their actual warranty is rather different. I can see why you might feel that Rab's message is misleading in the one instance and not at all clear in the other. But on balance I think your thread title and OP may be a little more alarmist than is really justified.
Did you really buy the garments because you thought that if anything whatever went wrong with them, no matter how long you'd had them or how much you'd worn them, they would be repaired or replaced? I'm not sure I'd expect that of any garment - though there are clearly other posters on this thread who report that such experiences can be had with other manufacturers.
FWIW I've been disappointed by one Rab garment (one of the original Vapour Rise jackets, on which the fabric pilled and wore badly very quickly, although everyone else seems to have thought were excellent) but I'm satisfied enough with my Baltoro Alpine jacket and my Neutrino belay jacket.