/ NEW REVIEW: Marmot Nabu NeoShell Jacket
In this review Toby Archer explains all...
Read more at http://www.ukclimbing.com/gear/review.php?id=5883
Nope, you can notice it when you have a long-sleeve base layer on, particularly when its sweaty.
I used my Neoshell jacket last Winter. Conditions were generally very good, with light winds being the norm.
There's no doubt that despite the good weather I felt quite a bit of air movement through it that you wouldn't get with a Goretex shell. I wouldn't call that a problem as such. The breathability of the material is excellent- which contrasts with my experience of Gore shells.
As Toby says in his Marmot jacket review, at least you can add a windproof layer when required (belay jacket, windshirt etc). You can't make a Gore type shell more wind permeable except by using pit zips etc.
That makes lots of sense David - the driclime obviously is a windproof layer. Will experiment more myself with this as the winter goes on.
By adding a windproof layer beneath the garment you are going to effect the breathability of your layering system and defeating the object of neoshell. Also, adding an insulated shell layer underneath (or any extra layer), to combat this negative side affect of air permeable membranes, will cause you to run hotter.
As I mentioned in the other thread, it's more than just feeling the wind coming through Neoshell that's the problem. It's the wind coming through a damp layer which acts like an air-conditioning unit, and is freezing cold (even when windchill alone is above freezing). The neoshell layer will always be damp as there's a constant exchange of moisture going on.
Mammut also states: "It combines the weather protection credentials of a hardshell with the outstanding moisture regulating performance of a softshell"
I always thought weather protection for a hardshell was wind and rain? Having used windproof layers that aren't waterproof over soaked base and mid layers I know that windproofing is vitally important to survival in the mountains.
I think that this marketing as "hardshell performance with softshell performance" needs to stop, and just call them waterproof softshells.
Exactly, but that is an increasingly unfashionable point of view. Lots of people do it, so you must be wrong.
But I've had softshells that were certainly not waterproof but were *effectively* windproof, in that I could not feel a stiff cold breeze through them despite only wearing a thin or medium baselayer underneath.
Of course you are, although I've always found things like Pertex and Marmot driclime breath plenty for me and I'm a hot, sweaty type on uphills
I guess only if your windproof layer isn't breathable at all.
Of course - adding any layers under a shell makes me sweatier if I'm going up hill.
Physics suggests this is true although that doesn't take into account the warmth gains that increased breathability should also offer. If you are wearing a less breathable jacket and sweat builds up wetting your under layers, then you will be losing heat by conduction too. Does one offset the other? Is one process more important than the other? Under what atmospheric conditions? Mr Fuller is probably the person best placed to discuss this; I suspect insulation/heat loss mechanisms on an exercising human will be very very complex with atmospheric conditions and individual physiology making things alter wildly.
But breathability is also important for hardshells, because if they lack this and you wet out your own base and midlayers, that also means you will lose heat rapidly. If gortex is wind protection 2, rain protection 3 and breathability 1, and neoshell is wp 1, rp 2 but breathability 3 (and of course those are completely made up values to illustrate a point) then you could say they are different approaches to offering the same level of protection?
From my experience of two different NeoShell jackets now I don't want to over-stress the air perm issue. Yes; I think it is MORE noticeable than Polartec claim, particularly under the conditions I point out. But it is not as if the material has no windproofing qualities at all. It is actually rather windproof; just not as much as Goretex*.
*Matt Fuller, IIRC, also pointed out that windproofness is a factor of they physical rigidity of the material as well. A soft light thin material (gore paclite for example) will deflect in wind and 'pump' air around inside your clothing possible causing convective heat loss. Probably lots of us have noticed that a heavyish 3 ply goretex mountain jacket with tough facing material is 'warmer' than a very light flexi paclite jacket for example.
Absolutely, my old Buffalo stuff always felt like that.
Yes, good point. A related issue is that thinner, flimsier materials get pressed against you by the cold wind you so you actually feel the cold more, esp if your baselayer is damp, whereas a stiffer fabric, or mid layer, will offer more of a barrier and so prevent this. Same cold, same wind, same conditions, (maybe) same number of layers, but a different experience due to the rigidity/thickness of the outer layer.
In Antarctica there have been several cases of frostbite in the inner thighs that I know of, that were caused by the effect of the cold wind pressing thin pants fabric hard against the inner thigh, while the people were pulling sleds into a headwind. Other people out in the same conditions, same place, same time, but with thicker pants had no problems at all.
Elsewhere on the site
From a personal point of view, photographing the night sky is one of the most difficult, frustrating yet ultimately rewarding... Read more
The Grivel A&D Ascender & Descender is brand new for Autumn 2014 and incorporates a revolutionary and innovative patented... Read more
Pete Whittaker has flashed the 32 pitch route Freerider 5.12d on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley over three days,... Read more
Nuts, wires, stoppers, chocks, wedges, whatever you want to call them, have been around for a long time. Initially made from... Read more
This survey is being conducted by the Outdoor Industries Association in order to find out more about how and why people... Read more