Derbyshire > Stanage Popular >
 
Macleod's Variation** VS 4c

Adjacent Climbs
<< Whillans' Pendulum and Black Magic
 
Hargreaves' Original Route >>
[Hargreaves' or Macleod's?, 2 kb]A variation finish from halfway up the slab feels like a cop-out. Shuffle left to climb the shallow groove and short crack. © ROCKFAX

Ticklists: 14 In A Day, Stanage Routes Graded List, Stanage 100 VD - VS, Peak Gritstone S-HVS **+.

Photo: Hargreaves' or Macleod's? © Jonathan Davey
Submit a new photo of this climb.

PUBLIC LOGBOOKS
This climb is in 176 logbooks, and on 5 wishlists.

DaveB61 - Lead - 15/Apr/14 with Greg Jennings

monkeyman79 - 2nd O/S - 11/Apr/14 with Dan Green, Dan Giblin

Petar Samkov - Lead O/S - 08/Apr/14

Lukem6 - Lead O/S - 24/Feb/14 with louise k

Nothing like as good as Hargreaves'.
Adam_42 - Lead O/S - 19/Jan/14 with David Noor

Hidden - Lead O/S - 29/Dec/13

MartinPL - Lead O/S - 20/Oct/13

dannyboy83 - Solo O/S - 05/Oct/13

Hidden - Lead O/S - 03/Sep/13

Hidden - 2nd - 16/Aug/13

dsgarner - Lead O/S - 16/Aug/13 with Jade Phillips, Dave Rosser

climb.jlr - Lead O/S - 04/Aug/13

tomthecoolperson - Lead O/S - 30/Jul/13 with Andrew

Hidden - Lead - 04/Jul/13

Hidden - 2nd - 04/Jul/13

popebenedictus - Lead O/S - 29/Jun/13 with Adrian Scott

jshields - Lead - 16/Jun/13 with Mike Dowsett, Ed James

the power - Lead - 01/Jun/13 with deacon

nai - Lead O/S - 17/May/13 with Andrew

Hidden - Lead O/S - 03/May/13

Gumery - Lead O/S - 27/Apr/13 with Clint

Not really that distinct from Hargreaves Original really, should just be "climb the slab wherever you want" as it makes little difference to the grade or climbing.
slacky - Lead O/S - 23/Apr/13 with Giulia Forlati, Dan Bilton

I started up but wimped out and sent Chris to fetch the gear :(
louby - 17/Feb/13 with Chris Burn

ashtond6 - Lead O/S - 17/Feb/13

Excellent fun, balancy climbing, basically the same as Hargreaves Original but with a simpler, shorter and easier finish. Very cold & windy, fingers and toes numb after about a minute of climbing! Rock was good though with no ice or water. The start is harder than I remember!
Stuart Hurworth - TR RP - 28/Jan/13 with Marcus Levens

I have seconded the normal version of Hargreave's original before....
JdotP - Lead β - 13/Jan/13 with The Chosen One, The Boy Wunda

LesserTrochanter - 2nd - 13/Jan/13 with Jonathan Davey, John Proctor

Hidden - Lead O/S - 05/Jan/13

tjsx101 - 2nd - 05/Jan/13 with Rob Middleton

Nick Sillem - Solo O/S - 2013

As good as the original.
Paul Hy - Lead O/S - 23/Nov/12 with Deacon

halroberts87 - 2nd - 21/Oct/12 with Jonny Schofield

JonnySchofield - Lead O/S - 21/Oct/12 with Hal

John Brayshaw - Lead O/S - 19/Oct/12 with Erica

erica - 2nd - 19/Oct/12 with John

Hidden - Lead O/S - 29/Sep/12

rich_hw - Lead O/S - 27/Sep/12 with Tracey

Hidden - Lead - 22/Sep/12

Joe.Elliott1 - 2nd - 22/Sep/12

buxtoncoffeelover - Lead - 14/Aug/12

Jonny M - Lead O/S - 13/Aug/12 with Karen Chalmers

The Pix - TR O/S - 13/Aug/12 with Jon Moulding

Hidden - Lead O/S - 12/Aug/12

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 12/Aug/12

deacondeacon - Lead O/S - 10/Aug/12

Some of the holds may have been a touch wet by the time I was seconding!
dpmUK - 2nd dog - 14/Jul/12 with Adam Carless

just finished before the rain hit, nice slab moves
adam carless - Lead O/S - 14/Jul/12 with dpmuk

patsaunders - Lead O/S - Jul/12

Dafydd Llywelyn - Solo O/S - 24/Jun/12

ross brinson - Lead - 25/May/12 with Hannah Watson

hannah watson - 2nd - 25/May/12 with Ross Brinson

Jake Young - Solo O/S - 05/May/12

Hidden - Lead O/S - 24/Mar/12

Have previously led Hargreaves.
gavinpeach - 2nd β - 18/Mar/12 with David Shelmerdine

I initially started out with the intention of climbing Hargreeves Original, but ended up doing this one!!!
David Shelmerdine - Lead - 18/Mar/12 with Gavin Peach

Pete Nugent - 2nd O/S - 01/Nov/11 with Dixie Flatline

joermann - Lead - 25/Oct/11

Falko - 2nd O/S - 19/Oct/11 with Steve M

stev1e.wilso - 2nd - 16/Oct/11 with Simon

simonhicklin - Lead - 16/Oct/11 with Steve Wilson

tsjx - 2nd - 01/Oct/11

Hidden - Lead O/S - 27/Sep/11

Hidden - 2nd - 27/Sep/11

ian d f - Lead O/S - 27/Sep/11 with Steve Robinson

cragtyke - 2nd - 26/Sep/11 with glenn

rocktigger - 2nd O/S - 05/Sep/11 with Ben

migs493 - Solo O/S - 06/Aug/11

Karl Wooffindin - Lead O/S - 01/Jul/11 with Bryce Rigler

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 21/Jun/11

Gambit - Lead O/S - 21/Jun/11 with Barney

The more natural line up the slab, though not as good as Hargreaves' Original.
Dan Lane - 2nd O/S - 20/Jun/11 with Mark Rankine

mark20 - Lead O/S - 20/Jun/11

nick ferro - 11/Jun/11

Hidden - Lead O/S - 05/Jun/11

hazeysunshine - 2nd O/S - 21/May/11 with Ann-Marie

Did we do M's Variation - or just a left-ish version of Hargreaves?
JohnHutch - Lead - 26/Apr/11 with Nik H, L

max_chan - Lead O/S - 12/Apr/11 with Trevor PCC

jacobjacob - Solo O/S - 09/Apr/11

JulesV - Solo rpt - 07/Apr/11

Hidden - TR O/S - 07/Apr/11

John Lewis - Lead O/S - 26/Mar/11 with Karl, Maureen

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 26/Mar/11

Hidden - Lead O/S - 21/Mar/11

jade - 2nd - 21/Mar/11 with andy

Gale force winds and 3C!
Andy Peak 1 - 08/Jan/11 with Atila

David Smith - 2011

PAJames - 2011

jade - 2nd - 2011 with andy

Hidden - Dec/10

Ewan Russell - Solo O/S - 14/Oct/10 with Myself!

Liam Ingram - Lead O/S - 02/Sep/10 with Fiona Mellor, Holly Spice

pabbage - 02/Aug/10

jon_gill1 - 2nd O/S - 26/Jul/10 with jigi

Hidden - Lead O/S - 25/Jul/10

richcwanders - Lead - 15/Jun/10

Hidden - Lead O/S - 27/May/10

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 27/May/10

Hidden - 2nd - 23/May/10

This was the first time leading on the Black Slab that I found the fun outweighed the tension. Am finally relishing those grit slopers.
Steve Waters, Mynydd - Lead - 23/May/10 with Mike Tempest

Hidden - Solo O/S - 18/May/10

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 16/May/10

Hidden - Solo O/S - 24/Apr/10

LakesWinter - 2nd - 24/Apr/10 with AD

Hidden - Solo - 21/Apr/10

Hidden - 08/Apr/10

Hidden - Solo - 11/Mar/10

Chris Craggs - 2nd - 07/Mar/10 with Graham Parkes

pie_eater_pete - 2010

RossG - 2010

Hidden - 2010

Adam1973 - Lead rpt - 04/Oct/09 with Ann S

Hidden - Solo - 23/Sep/09

frume - Lead O/S - 21/Sep/09 with Saff

Jon Dittman - 2nd - 22/Aug/09

b.hayley - 2nd O/S - 08/Aug/09 with alfredo

Alfredo - Lead - 08/Aug/09 with Ben H

maybe_si - Solo O/S - 03/Aug/09

Very good. The slopers don't stop till the short crack right at the top.
D Berry - Lead O/S - 24/Jul/09 with Claire Berry

Hidden - Lead O/S - 18/Jul/09

Brown - Solo O/S - 09/Jul/09 with Henry

Hidden - Lead O/S - 02/Jul/09

Like Hargreaves' the adjectival grade of this depends on the composition of your rack! Nice climbing on grippy slopers.
PaulWatson - 2nd O/S - 14/Jun/09 with Paul

lovely
Tanya Savage - 2nd - 13/Jun/09 with Neil Pacey

Neil Pacey - Lead O/S - 13/Jun/09 with Tanya Savage

Hidden - Solo O/S - 09/Jun/09

Hidden - Solo - 24/May/09

howlingbaboon - Lead O/S - 21/May/09 with Chris FitzHugh

Hidden - 2nd - 05/Apr/09

Hidden - Apr/09

SteveM - Lead O/S - 21/Feb/09 with Andy

Goose4 - 2009

barni - Lead O/S - 31/Oct/08 with Jack

Tended left-ish rather than right, so probably did this one rather than Hargreaves?
JohnHutch - Lead - 19/Sep/08 with SC

Hidden - Solo O/S - 15/Sep/08

Sardien - 2nd O/S - 17/Aug/08 with Toby Vye, Emlyn W. Roberts, Nigel Milner

tobydunford - 2nd β - 16/Aug/08

hailtryfan - 2nd O/S - Jul/08 with Costas

mr bounce - Lead O/S - 24/Jun/08 with Neil Hardy

nrhardy - 2nd O/S - 24/Jun/08 with Tim

Blisco - 2nd - 07/Jun/08 with Keith Ridgeway

petemeads - Solo - 05/Jun/08

Hidden - Lead O/S - 29/May/08

Take some big cams for the top half of the route, otherwise it can be pretty scary! :(
Nick Smith - UKC - Lead O/S - 21/May/08 with bluebrad

Hidden - Lead O/S - 07/May/08

mikej - Lead - 22/Apr/08 with Rick Naylor

Hidden - AltLd - 11/Apr/08

Hidden - Lead O/S - 13/Mar/08

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 13/Mar/08

Byronius Maximus - 2nd O/S - 10/Feb/08 with Alex Twist

Bold for first route
Twisty - Lead rpt - 09/Feb/08 with Byron Buck

mic_b - Lead O/S - 22/Jan/08 with fruitcake72

Rachel Somerville - Lead O/S - 01/Oct/07 with Robin Mitton

Adam1973 - Lead O/S - 16/Sep/07 with philnorv

Hidden - 2nd - 09/Jun/07

Graeme Hammond - Lead O/S - 08/Jun/07 with Alex Twist

Twisty - 2nd O/S - 08/Jun/07 with Graeme Hammond

Hedley - Lead O/S - 25/May/07 with Tim Hammell

timharrison - 2nd O/S - 24/May/07 with Hedley Proctor

Rampikino - Lead - 28/Apr/07 with Cat

This is probably the way I did Black Slab orginally - does have a couple of hard moves
Chris the Tall - Solo O/S - 03/Feb/07

Hidden - 2007

Another James - Lead O/S - 03/Sep/06 with Kirsten S

crossdressingrodney - Lead O/S - 08/Jul/06 with victim of mathematics

victim of mathematics - 2nd O/S - 08/Jul/06 with crossdressingrodney

Hidden - Solo - 2004

Hidden - Lead - 23/Sep/00

Hidden - 2000

Simon Pearce - 1999

Hidden - Lead O/S - 01/May/90

Iain Thow - Lead - 11/Sep/88 with Sally (Aston), Helen Jones

Hidden - Lead - 1984

Hidden - Lead - 03/Jul/83

rogerskews - 1972

mikej - Solo - 27/Dec/69 with Dave Williams, Ted Markham

mikej - Lead - 01/May/66 with Mike Byles

mikej - Lead - 24/Oct/65 with Howard Furguson

Users with this climb on their wishlist are:
Hidden, Hidden, Nigel Bond, JanBella, Hidden

Voting
Total votes cast 68
hard HVS0 of 24
HVS0 of 24
easy HVS0 of 24
hard VS3 of 24
VS18 of 24
easy VS3 of 24
hard HS0 of 24
HS0 of 24
easy HS0 of 24
hard 5a0 of 22
5a0 of 22
easy 5a0 of 22
hard 4c1 of 22
4c19 of 22
easy 4c2 of 22
hard 4b0 of 22
4b0 of 22
easy 4b0 of 22
3 Stars5 of 22
2 Stars16 of 22
1 Star1 of 22
0 Stars0 of 22
Bag of .....0 of 22
Please Login as Existing User to rate this climb.
Style of ascent

Soloed22 of 176 (12.5%)
Lead86 of 176 (48.9%)
Followed47 of 176 (26.7%)
Toproped3 of 176 (1.7%)
Alt Leads1 of 176 (0.6%)
Unknown17 of 176 (9.7%)

'Climbed'70 of 176 (39.8%)
clean O/S98 of 176 (55.7%)
clean β3 of 176 (1.7%)
clean rpt3 of 176 (1.7%)
clean RP1 of 176 (0.6%)
dogged1 of 176 (0.6%)