/ NEWS: Kevin Jorgeson Repeats The Promise
In his short report to UKC, Kevin Jorgeson stated simply:
"Second ascent today. Did it in an hour on my first day and thought E8 was more appropriate. I'm writing a trip report that I will post on my site shortly."
Read More: http://www.ukclimbing.com/news/older.html?month=10&year=2008#n45410
EDIT: Oct 28: The Promise - Kevin's account at http://www.ukclimbing.com/news/older.html?month=10&year=2008#n45411
Lets hope conditions continue for them!
I remember what a nasty landing that had and how tenuous the moves sounded when listening to JP on Committed.
From his blog:
"Today I managed to climb The Promise at Burbage North for its second ascent. On my initial inspection two
days ago on rappel, I didnt even try the moves. The original beta just seemed completely out of the question.
Returning today, looking at the chalk on the holds, I visualized a new possibility for the beta and gave it a try.
This involved turning a right hand pocket to an undercling, which as a result shortened the reach to a bad sloper.
I quickly did the moves with the new beta on top rope, rested, and climbed it clean on top rope. After figuring
out how to place the slider nut, which was surprisingly bomber, I was ready to go. I climbed up, placed the
piece and returned to the ground. On the lead, there always seems to be some unplanned decision to be made.
For me, it was the position of my right foot on a key hold relative to the rope. This unplanned decision resulted
in me placing my right foot a little wrong, requiring a readjustment. Once in place, the crux move felt quite a bit
harder than I was anticipating. Luckily, there was enough tolerance in the move that I was still able to stick it.
The whole process took about an hour."
"The obvious question that arose was regarding the grade. After climbing Parthian Shot, The New Statesman,
and The Promise and having spent two days on Equilibrium and one on The Groove, my opinion is that the
grade falls at E8, 5.13c/d R. The reason for this is that a fall from the crux would not result in a ground fall,
assuming the gear holds. Regarding the gear, the only way that it would fail is if the cables broke. After bounce
testing the piece while clipped directly into my harness, I was confident that it would hold. It should also be
stated that I placed two crashpads at the base of the climb. All in all, the route climbs wonderfully and would
highly recommend it to anyone!"
If I've not misread the text, Kevin has put E-grades in the photocaptions for some US highballs: The Swarm V10 E10
> If I've not misread the text, Kevin has put E-grades in the photocaptions for some US highballs: The Swarm V10 E10
You must have mis-read as it's the duel he thinks is E10, not the swarm.
> You must have mis-read as it's the duel he thinks is E10, not the swarm.
That's correct and confirmed.
I thought I'd changed that.
www.momentumvm.com: "This line is called 'the Duel' and goes at about V10, but will likely never be repeated."
Now there's a gauntlet.
> Thanks Adam,
> I thought I'd changed that.
> www.momentumvm.com: "This line is called 'the Duel' and goes at about V10, but will likely never be repeated."
> Now there's a gauntlet.
I've stood under The Duel, and the landing is shocking....
Does this make The Walk of Life E10 then?
Echoes of the brothers Menestrel...
Kevin is going through the hard stuff like a good dose!! i wonder if he'll visit Scotland and Cornwall?
In reply to flaneur:
> From his blog:
> and The Promise and having spent two days on Equilibrium and one on The Groove, my opinion is that the
> grade falls at E8, 5.13c/d R.
In global grade esperanto that is 8a+/b French sport with the R being the Yosemite Decimal System (YDS) protection grade.
G Good, solid protection ground up
PG Pretty good, few sections of poor or non-existent placements
R Runout, some protection placements may be very far apart (possibility of broken bones, even when properly protected)
X No protection, extremely dangerous (possibility of death, even when properly protected)
is that the greade for all of them? statesman has always been E8, should parthian stay at E9 given that at the time no one even dared think about testing the flake?
just The Promise I think.
ahh i see, since he's flying through these hard routes like a speeding bullet it'd be good to hear that he's been on McLeods and pearsons routes in sctland and cornwall!
If he does get on the i wonder if he'll try ground up considering the seriousness of them?
> I've stood under The Duel, and the landing is shocking....
From Rock and Ice, December 2008!
In an interview with Aliosn Osius, Kevin Jorgeson was asked.
What might be your most dangerous problem?
"Probably The Dual in Hueco. I fell off the crux probably half a dozen times on top rope, so the chance of a fall was reasonable, and you'd pinball.
I didn't even have spotters because it really wouldn't have done anything. I think I'd have been putting them in more danger than putting me in safety. Most of my problems I've had three to four spotters."
The Duel is V10, 25 feet and Kevin has stated to UKClimbing.com that he thinks it would get an E10 grade.
Also see:... I think Kevin has done most if not all of the below.
Apr 26 2007: E-grades for American Highball Boulder Problems
by Mick Ryan
In an interesting twist, Wills Young of Bishop, sent us a list of highball boulder problems around Bishop, California, that he has assigned E-grades to.
The Ninth V7 (Pollen Grains, Matt Wilder, Nov. 2005) E6
This Side of Paradise V10 (Bardini Boulders, Matt Wilder, Nov. 2005) E7
Flight of the Bumblebee V9 (Secrets of the Beehive Area, Kevin Jorgeson, Jan. 2007) E8
Evilution V11/12 (Peabody Boulders, Jason Kehl, Nov. 2002) E8
Pick of the crop is The Beautiful and the Damned V13 at the Bardini Boulders first climbed by Kevin Jorgeson this last January and given a proposed E-grade of E9. This monster got a repeat by Ethan Pringle, another American climber who is making waves like Jorgeson, both of whom Wills describes as world-class climbers.
Going well that boy. Good effort.
Very interesting to read his thoughts on the route and the grade. Is he purely a highball and short route devotee, or is he likely to travel to try the hard routes away from grit?
>"If he does get on the i wonder if he'll try ground up considering the seriousness of them?"
The problems associated with a beta free ground up of Rhapsody will be route finding given its line is escapeable at lower difficulty, technical difficulty of the moves if the correct line is followed and remaining beta free. I think the seriousness element has gone since it's been proven that multiple falls don't mean certain injury.
(Still I wouldn't fancy it myself like.)
I think the right person could ground up Rhapsody but it's probably unrealistically without beta. Anyway who'd ever come to climb it without having seen video and pictures of guys on it?
It must be practically impossible to escape aquiring beta for such notable climbs. I've got more beta for Rhapsody than I had for Three Peeble Slab when I did it.
anyone got a photo or video of Duel?
cheers. I've registered but still can't find the video. Any clues as to how I find it?
If not, look in Archives, issue#12, January 2008, Kevin Jorgeson highball FAs in Hueco.
I would love to see some of these guys coming over to Ireland and having a go at Divided Years...there's an E9 (?) of significant length (45m) which is safe and should be ground-uppable I'd have thought...
awesome, thanks. It's a shame that you don't get a true feel of the height of the route when he's climbing though.
Could be? Might not be?
Could be? Might not be
That's an interesting one - ie contrasting 2 similarly flawed styles. The best style is also normally the hardest way to do a route but just because its easier one way doesnt mean its a worse style or vice versa. Also from the outset you dont know how much/little falls/yo-yos or top roping is required for success.
I think it comes down to what an individual interprets as 'best' and that in turn would depend on your ethic or pre-disposed climbing style. On the other hand praticality might force the style you employ if you only have a limited time available and are desperate to do the route.
To illustrate my point, look at Andy Pollitt's ground up ascent of Chimes of Freedom, an 8a+ at Raven Tor in the mid 80's which took about 15 days or something (it was 7c+ at the time as it had an extra crucial block that has since fallen out). This was just before the redpointing boom when 'dogging' moves was frowned upon and you had to lower to the ground immediately if you fell. If he had been able to redpoint, he would have probably done it in about 2 or 3 days! Ground ups of sport routes thankfully never caught on after Andy's ascent. This is why I question the point of ground ups of reasonably protected trad routes. Surely the onsight/ flash is the great prize and after that is gone, you may as well just headpoint??
Surely the onsight/ flash is the great prize and after that is gone, you may as well just headpoint??
I think I pretty much agree with that, though obviously it depends on the individual's attitude to it...all depends on the sense of accomplishment you take from each approach I suppose.
If a route is safe though, as Divided Years is, why not go for the flash? If you fail, as you say, you can always change your approach afterwards...
> If a route is safe though, as Divided Years is, why not go for the flash?* If you fail, as you say, you can always change your approach afterwards...
*if you think you're capable of course!
IIRC from his lecture from waay back Pollitt elected to do it this way almost as an experiment. He redpointed all his other hard sport routes at the time.
Also choice of style isnt necessarily about what is impressive to others but what an individual feels is the right thing to do. There might be an internal dialogue of what is practical and quick vs what is better style vs come back to it another year.
>If a route is safe though, as Divided Years is,
Am I out of date here? I seem to recall it being said there was very dangerous but easier climbing after the hardest part.
> >If a route is safe though, as Divided Years is,
> Am I out of date here? I seem to recall it being said there was very dangerous but easier climbing after the hardest part.
Certainly Dunne said that the top arete (above the crux) was worth E7 6c in its own right, and that a fall from the 6c bit at the top would be disastrous. But other ascentionists have made no conspicuous mention of this.
Perhaps 'comparatively' safe, or safe for the grade. I understood you could take massive but harmless falls on most of it at least..?
Exactly, in my view life is too short for ground upping on reasonably protected trad routes (grit excepted). It could take weeks to do this for Rhapsody to prove not a great deal.
Or the lakes.
.........and, while we're on the subject, have you two not noticed its been pi**ing down in the Lakes and Scotland for two months!
Any chance we could get him on Three Pebble Slab, and sort that one out?
There is, however, an unrepeated E10 in Cornwall.
I don't think Kevin Jorgeson has been trying anything harder, has he ?
Anybody seen James Pearsons blog today.
Sounds like the suggested downgrade caused a raised eyebrow or two from him!
I know :-)
Equally it would be nice to see E10s on different rock types attempted because the E grade isn't all about grit.
It would be pretty interesting to get them to have a go at some of Birketts routes..
> It would be pretty interesting to get them to have a go at some of Birketts routes..
especailly since no matter how hard they may be he hasn't graded anything E10(i think)
"They [bouldering mats] are also commonly used to take the sting out of bolder routes. This is entirely your choice, and in many ways a rational one, but remember the effect their use will have on the grade of a climb. It makes them easier."
-- Stanage. The Definitive Guide. © BMC 2007.
Elsewhere on the site
Last year, Finn McCann wrote an article about climbing El Capitan with his terminally ill father Seamus, who had been... Read more
A fantastically versatile little pack; whether out running in the hills, hitting the trails on the bike or just running for the... Read more
Manchester Climbing Centre is showing Reel Rock’s Valley Uprising on Tuesday the 11th of November at... Read more
Pete Whittaker has flashed the 32 pitch route Freerider 5.12d on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley over three days,... Read more