/ Ratho Grades soft???
which of the 7b's do you think are 6c+?
I definitely agree, even in comparison with Alien Rock I think Ratho grades are a touch soft. Having said that, Ratho is a bit different from many walls, with a typical route being longer and steeper but less technical -- so grades will be a bit hard to compare.
Bouldering at Ratho uses V-grades so I assume the OP is talking about French sports grades. (OP - using capital letters e.g. 6C can imply a Font bouldering grade)
I always thought something similar, although I assumed that it was because the routes were longer and so a lower grade would be experienced as more difficult.
The routes thre are much longer and more sustained than most other walls, so the grades (correctly) reflect this accordingly. It's just another type of grade 'x', same as outdoors.
I must say, none of the 7b's I've been on have felt like 6c+. Which ones are you thinking of?
Genuinely no offence meant here, but looking at the grades on your profile's climb list and you're dogging F6a+ routes at Kirriehill....are you really best placed to suggest the grading of F7b routes are soft?
Hmm, that's interesting, because when I've tried to TR routes about that grade, I find them feeling harder than the lead equivalent. (I'd assumed that they factored in the fact you are on a TR.) There are a couple of F7b's to the rhs of the tower which feel pretty punchy for 7B - one I couldn't get past a stopper-move at 1/2 or 2/3 height, so I'd definitely say that one wasn't soft.
Overall, though I've generally found the (leading) routes at Ratho to be well graded. I've not climbed at that many other walls tbh, but compared to outdoors routes, I think they're pretty accurate. The setters are all a very decent bunch and have climbed extensively, so in theory at least, they should know what a given grade is. I understand that Gaz Vincent now grades all the routes (it might just be the lead ones however) and he's pretty gnarly - I find the routes he sets to be among the hardest for their grade.
Agree. Climbed there a couple of times this year leading or attempting up to 7b on the routes on the main wall and they were either bang-on or hard for the grade.
I think the routes you are talking about were set for a Youth Series Competition a few weeks ago. I understand that such routes tend to start easy and get harder, which may account for the impression of under-grading.
...or even over-grading! :-)
Pretty sure it's not the comp. routes - see 12:30 post: he/she's talking about top rope routes, but I'm not yet sure which ones.
I thought the French grade was given for the hardest part of the climb, and didn't reflect length. The limited amount of sports climbing I've done in France seemed to fit in with this view. I'd be grateful if someone could shed more light on this.
> I thought the French grade was given for the hardest part of the climb, and didn't reflect length. The limited amount of sports climbing I've done in France seemed to fit in with this view. I'd be grateful if someone could shed more light on this.
The French grade is for the whole route.
If it is cruxy or has a an especially hard section the grade will focus on that.
Conversely if length has a bearing on the overall difficulty with it being continuously pumpy with poor rests without individually hard moves then the grade willl focus on that.
Comparisons are usually drawn with benchmark routes of similar character to arrive at a grade.
Probably not best placed to comment as I've only climber at Ibrox and Ratho and at about 6a+, but I'd agree that the route length is taken into account at Ratho. The 6a up the tower is barely more than a ladder, there are harder 5's at Ibrox, but it does go on for substantially longer. The shorter length routes all felt comparable to me, in fact most were a little tougher than I expected.
Ahhhh yes! Now I remember - someone telling me one of those harder TR routes in that area was the 7 y.o. girls' route or something! <:-?
Sounds like you must have been on the 7 year old girls YCS Final route, super easy up until the last 3 moves...
Elsewhere on the site
2014 has been a bumper year for climbing publications. Here's a few of the ones that we have either read, or ones that we... Read more
The British climbing scene is very exciting at the moment. It is quite clear that as a sport it is developing at a rapid rate and... Read more
On the run up to Christmas we have some great savings on all your favourite brands, so its the perfect time to do the... Read more
Hot Aches Productions premiered their latest film Redemption: The James Pearson Story at Kendal Mountain Festival on... Read more
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more