/ Single point of failure anchor
As the anchor is a thread I was thinking of threading a length of chain with an abseil ring. I was going to connect the ends with a D-ring/half circle Mallion and add two lower off rings to this (which could then be replaced if they get worn). However, this would be a single point and if any part of the chain or linkages got damaged and broke, it would be a clean 50 meter drop. Material would be Fixe A304 Stainless Steel.
I looked at your post, thought "earl of Perth" and then checked your logbook...
What's wrong with a dirty great big loop of rope - say 11mm static or something, although I'm pretty sure almost any thick rope would do - with a big Mallion or lower off ring on it? Probably easier for climbers to judge its safety, since it's a familiar material, potentially cheaper, and will last for ages. It's the way they equipped the fixed belays in the pass atop things like left wall etc, so it's clearly a workable solution.
If it is strong enough then it is strong enough, just another single point of failure like... the rope, the knot, the harness loop, the belay device, the crab......you are probably getting my drift!
Many sport routes have a chain with a ring joining two bolts. In the end it is the choice of the climber to use it or not as they think fit.
Mail me, I may have what you want in my loft.
I was thinking something similar, although I was wondering about a swaged cable. The cheapest might be a single piece of 11mm static rope and a maillon or glued steel krab (as on the tree above Nightmare). I think there is a case for the ab anchor above Suspense to be improved too - last time I was there I noticed a groove being worn into the rock behind it, which is causing ropes to be harder to pull down and increasing the wear every time people descend. I meant to mention it previously, but forgot. Is there an easy, single place we can make suggestions to the Steering group?
Now? Of course not. Ten years down the line, when it's old and worn and looking a bit worse for wear, who knows? Tat will appear next to anything given enough time. In general though unless someone is going to take responsibility for maintaining it I don't see a benefit in having a big fixed thing like a chain over something that any climber could easily replace should they feel it's time to do so.
From memory I also don't know how big the gap behind the anchor is so whilst I am pretty confident you could get some thick rope through, whether you could get a chain of a similar size to the one on Gimmer, say, through it I don't really remember. I seem to recall most of the tat was like 5-6mm stuff, which implies to me that the gap isn't really that huge. Perhaps cable like the one round the tree at High Tor would be better if it's in a constricted location.
I had a good look at the anchor and I'm pretty sure there's room for 3/8" chain. There's a fair bit of clearance round the back.
I'm not sure on the exact lifespan but i'm pretty sure marine grade stainless would be good for 10-20 years? My only problem with static is that the sheath starts to look tatty relatively quickly (months not years) and so people add their cord/tat to it and the process starts again. Yeah it's not the end of the world by any means. I just thought the buttress would be a good candidate for a slightly more permanent solution. Particularly as there's 10-15 well travelled lines and they all share two anchors.
The only reason it really bothers me is the first time I climbed there I saw people threading their ropes (through the actual anchor/over the top of the tat) which meant that when they pulled their ropes, it could have really damaged the tat.
Definitely worth bringing up at the next area meeting IMHO. I think a piece of chain will wind some folk up. Wouldn't bother me, but I'm sure someone would get upset.
However personally, I'd just re-climb the route with a suitable piece of tat, cut all the existing crud and put the new tat in. If it's a good/popular route, I'd try and make the effort to climb it every so often, putting a new piece of tat and stripping the crud each time.
I know of a couple of routes near to me which will be getting similar treatment next time I climb them, as I thought at the time 'ohh that tat is awful' and now a year later it'll be even worse.
Elsewhere on the site
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more
2014 has been a bumper year for climbing publications. Here's a few of the ones that we have either read, or ones that we... Read more
Nick Livesey discovered the mountains of Snowdonia over a decade ago and finally moved there a year and a half ago, quitting a... Read more
If asked to name a British female climber who stood out at a time when British women's climbing wasn't... Read more
A product review by James Turnbull. James Turnbull at Outside recently took the new Osprey Mutant 38 on a rigorous test in the... Read more