/ Is 1200 calories (net) enough? And what afterwards?
For the last three weeks I have limited intake to net 1200 cals i.e. if I have been for a long run then this will offset the additional calories.
My food has been a mixture of high protein, vegetables and cutting down on the refined carbs. Not eating really late and plenty of exercise - I can even notch up 250 cals by taking the dog for two brisk half hour walks per day. In a nutshell, I'm measuring everything.
My aim is lower BMI, 165 lbs - currently 169.6 at today's weight in.
When I reach 165lbs I want to lean up but not get any lower in weight.
I'm think that if I increase to 1500 net afterwards, increasing the weights slightly, but not too much as I want to have a sensible size for running and climbing.
What are your views.
Sounds very low to me, but i'm much bigger, so maybe just have a different frame of reference!
I've been looking into a similar approach and found that the weight loss sites recommended calcualting your Basal Metabolic Rate, then adding your activity as a multiplier and then taking 20% off making sure that your calorie intake does not drop below your BMR. However, when i do this (from a baseline of being a proper fatty who does a fair bit of cardio) the amount of calories it shows me needing to eat to be above BMR feels hugely high...
Quick google says at 165lbs and 5'10 (no idea how tall you are of course!) your BMR would be 1700ish, add on cardio, then take off 20% would mean more like 1600 than 1200 as a target intake. But as i said i'm not totally sold on this concept yet even though it does make sense in principle...
No expert but if you are losing weight whilst limiting yourself to 1200 calories then it is not 'enough' otherwise you would maintain a steady weight.
It'll probably be a bit of trial and error to get the intake right when you reach your target weight but varying a couple of kilos either side isn't going to cause you any problems and you'll get a feel for it after a while. I don't think counting everything is going to be a good long term plan as you risk becoming obsessive about it which isn't fun for anyone. Everything in moderation and be as active as possible is my goal and I maintain a fairly steady weight and physique (weight training bores me).
Good effort on the weight loss - well done.
> Sounds very low to me, but i'm much bigger, so maybe just have a different frame of reference!
> I've been looking into a similar approach and found that the weight loss sites recommended calcualting your Basal Metabolic Rate, then adding your activity as a multiplier and then taking 20% off making sure that your calorie intake does not drop below your BMR. However, when i do this (from a baseline of being a proper fatty who does a fair bit of cardio) the amount of calories it shows me needing to eat to be above BMR feels hugely high...
> Quick google says at 165lbs and 5'10 (no idea how tall you are of course!) your BMR would be 1700ish, add on cardio, then take off 20% would mean more like 1600 than 1200 as a target intake. But as i said i'm not totally sold on this concept yet even though it does make sense in principle...
I'm 5' 8" (and a bit :))
Take today as an example though. My day started with a dog walk so that can take my cals to 1330 plus a sub 25min 5k later today together with some more strength training which will burn over 400 cals so I am looking at calorie intake to closer to 1650-1700. on a long run day I am eating closer to 2200-2400cals.
I perhaps sound more obsessive than i actually am. Its easy to estimate weights of food when you've done a but of proper weighing and I will allow myself half a bottle of red tonight so I'm not losing out on all the fun as well.
I was just tired of being overweight and now my BMI, according to NHS online, is 25.82 from closer to 27 at Xmas, which I'm really pleased about.
That's exactly what I plans to do although the downside to all this is that all my work suits no longer fit me properly around the waist. Also more nicer to get into medium and 'fitted/tailored' shirts again.
You will burn more fat overall by eating your full daily requirements as a healthy diet and then adding exercise on top. You will also have more energy to exercise longer and harder
>is 1200 calories enough?
No. I'm pretty sure that the reccommendation would be running at a deficit of around 500 kcal maximum.
Of course as has been pointed out above calorie counting (both what you eat, and what you expend - basal rate + exercise) is not an exact science.
You're probably better off experimenting and varying dependent on weight loss and energy levels.
Since you are doing the calculating thing though, let's follow that through: Assuming:
Basal Rate: 2500kcal/day
'net' intake: 1200kcal/day
all weight loss due to fat
energy density of fat: 9g/kcal
Then: deficit = 1300kcal/day
or loss of 1300/9 = 144g.fat/day
or 1kg per weeek
So weight loss of 1kg per week which is probably too much to be in any way sustainable. Also in practice not all weight loss will be fat, some will be protein which has a lower energy density making for even more weight loss.
The deficit should not be from bmr but should e from your tdee which is your bmr + your other activities. Ii think you're supposed to remain above your bmr. Although I am far from expert.
So the only activity you do all day is:-
a) Take dog for walk
b) strength training.
You burn calories up just by being alive. What about the calories you use during the rest of the day and night. Add those in too.
Nope, depends on the day.
Today Ive done feckall but tomorrow will be bouldering, Monday long run, Tuesday strength and circuit, Wednesday, short quick run etc. There's no particular routing, just what feels right on the day.
Elsewhere on the site
The Kendal Mountain Festival 2014 proved once again to be a busy and inspiring four days of films, photos, music, art... Read more
2012 saw the release of the beautiful first volume of definitive Yorkshire Gritstone climbing, produced by the YMC with Robin... Read more
Backpackers want an extremely liveable and lightweight tent at good price. MSR answers the call with the Elixir 2 tent and... Read more
Skiing Baffin’s couloirs has been on my to do list ever since I saw Andrew McLean and Brad Barlage’s inspirational... Read more
The Women's Mountain Equipment Cho Oyu Jacket is the perfect choice for female mountaineers an explorers who... Read more