In reply to mike kann:
> There you go. That's a sweeping generalisation.
I didn't say that I hadn't made any generalisations.
> "then a membrane makes certain that you won't get wet"
So I pointed out that this was an over generalisation and incorrect which it is, instead of agreeing with me you felt the need to try and pick holes in my other posts on this thread. Is this really necessary?
> Gore windstopper is a membrane that is more breathable than Goretex. And
> it's generally accepted that Goretex is more breathable than most macs.
Since I was aware that many of the membranes are breathable in softshells its pretty clear I was comparing to other breathable waterproofs. Mac was meant as a throwaway slang term not sure why you needed to take what I said quite so literally.
> And the fact that many windstopper garments get heavy when wet is
> because they are combined with heavy face and backing fabrics which hold
> water, not because of the membrane itself.
Did you really think I meant the membrane itself became saturated and heavy ? Surely not!
> Just pointing out that membranes if put in the right combination can
> work exceedingly well - eg my Alpine Direct seam sealed bibs, which
> breath well, have excellent ventilation when you need it, act as a
> hardshell when you need it and gives you a reasonable compromise between
> the two.
Maybe for you but not for me, not everyone's the same you know.