In reply to pebbles:
> what he needs is a strong minded sub editor with a red pencil to go through his articles and cut out the bits where he goes off into hyperspace
<<finds guantlet on the floor and decides to pick it up>>
Here's my translation;
I think people are missing JR’s central point and getting side tracked by what they feel is his antiquated and misogynistic attitude towards women. I think the language JR uses doesn’t help in this respect, but putting that to one side, I feel the point he is driving at is an important one. With that in mind I will paraphrase what I believe JR has written.
JR states a number of times why he has written this piece; “My plea is for a perspective, because I feel something has been forgotten”, he also quotes Lao Tzu about ‘walking the great way’, and he writes “We sit on the shoulders of giants, remembering nothing”. This is about reminding us about the way we live, and the lessons we have all, to a greater or lesser extent forgotten.
His piece is about understanding who we are as human beings, the choices we have in life, and more importantly how those choices will lead us either to a life of fulfilment and peace or a life of increasing neediness and dissatisfaction. JR has chosen to use our concept of femininity to explore this, and in doing so he has made life difficult for himself! He has expanded our modern/western notion of femininity to represent the embodiment of ‘the knowledge’ which leads us to a more grounded life. While he uses masculinity as the embodiment of those choices which lead us to discontentment and alienation. He isn’t alone in using this analogy (belief), this is a notion which runs through many belief systems; mother earth, venus, pachamama, to name a few.
However, the notion of feminine-masculine, light-dark, yin-yang, call it what you like, is really just window dressing, the central theme is about understanding how to navigate a fulfilling life through a difficult world. JR’s beef is that much, indeed nearly all of the navigation tools we are supplied with are leading us down a dangerous path. In a society where our values, our navigational tools, are increasingly determined by powerful commercial interests, where people are feeling increasingly alienated and dissatisfied, we need to stop and think about the beliefs we hold, the choices we make and the repercussions they have. The landscape and our interaction with it, for example through climbing, provides us with a space beyond ourselves in which we can find and engage with an alternative narrative.
I agree with some of the comments criticizing the language JR uses and the apparent meaning behind that language, but for me these details need to be forgiven, the guy is only human, his piece is trying to convey a difficult narrative, one which few are capable of writing clearly and coherently about. But it is an important narrative, one which sits in the background whilst drowned out by louder voices. I for one commend JR for trying to bring this narrative back to the forefront of our attention.