In reply to greylag:
> Having lived in Penrith and knowing Kendal relatively well (though not lived there) Kendal would get my vote from what you've asked for.
> Kendal wall - tick
Yeah - will give you that, but there's Penrith wall, Keswick just down the road & huge amounts of real rock
> Access to Lakes/Scotland - tick
Arguably better from Penrith than Kendal - unless you're fixated on Langdale - Penrith better placed for the motorway & rail links (cos Oxenholme doesn't count)
> Transport links - tick
see above
> Kendal Calling - has it's own festival
in Penrith
> More of tree hugging community than Penrith has....
maybe, but if that's what you want...
and if he wants culture, Rheged & Theatre in Keswick pretty good, Booths for posh nosh, good curry house, okish pubs, lakes that are pleasant! and if you choose to live in Penrith/Eden valley, cheaper housing! the cinema is 19th century, however...