Thought this tough for the grade when I led it 4 years ago and I haven't changed my mind...
cem - 2nd rpt - 16/Oct/14 with Chris Gudgeon
Agree with Andy (Deacon) about grade - middle section has some tough moves with just about adequate gear!
Gudge - Lead O/S - 16/Oct/14 with Charles Moreton
TimG - 2nd O/S - 23/Aug/14 with John
jh1990 - Lead O/S - Aug/14
Move at mid-height off the gaston was pretty tough
MTL - 2nd O/S - 04/Jul/14 with Donnie
papashango - Lead O/S - 01/Jul/14 with Martin
Hidden - Lead O/S - 10/Sep/13
widdlestickmcpoos - 08/Sep/13
the power - Lead dnf - 03/Aug/13 with paul29uk
Hidden - 2nd dnf - 03/Aug/13
Used the arÍte for the first couple of moves
Anne Gumbley - 2nd - 30/Jun/13 with Ruairidh Wadsworth, Harry Middleton
Having a bad day but this felt nails, managed to keep off any good holds and it felt E2 5c to me.
Shame its so eliminate and escapable as the moves are very good.
deacondeacon - Lead O/S - 21/Jun/13
gavinpeach - 2nd O/S - 21/Jun/13 with Andrew Deacon
john lynch - Lead O/S - 15/May/13 with Joe Holden, ed luke
jwpil - Lead O/S - 12/Oct/12 with Deacon
Matt Cooke - Lead β - 01/Sep/12 with Rosh
Wow this was hard for E1 5b! More like E2 5c for me (170cm). Quite a bit harder than Great Buttress Arete (same grade in book) and more sustained and more committing than Thrown Away just left again. Hard to keep the blinkers on and keep direct up the centre of the slab and I found the finish over the rocking block really hard. All that said, it is a good route though
martroberts - Lead O/S - 27/Jun/12
jon59 - 2nd - 13/Jun/12
joemallia - 2nd O/S - 10/Jun/12 with Jill Whittaker
Ed F - Lead O/S - 30/Oct/11
Hidden - Lead O/S - 26/Oct/11
some nice moves but ridiculously contrived since you have to keep going back to the arete to place gear. start would be harder for anyone under about 5' 9"
Alex@home - 2nd β - 26/Oct/11 with Tony Moody
Jim Slater - 2nd O/S - 08/Jul/11 with Trevor
Lev - Lead O/S - 11/Apr/11 with Emma Ross
Hidden - 2nd dog - 11/Apr/11
disturbed_one51 - Lead - 02/Apr/11 with Wee man
Jonathan Hall - 2nd - 02/Apr/11 with Mark Williams
mwatson - 2011
Hidden - 2nd - 10/Oct/10
Hidden - Lead O/S - 10/Jul/10
riven - 2nd O/S - 05/Jun/10 with Pete
Might have avoided some of the main difficulties on this - rather an eliminate.
petellis - Lead O/S - 05/Jun/10 with Joe Barker
cem - Lead O/S - 08/May/10 with Dave Amos
Hidden - Lead O/S - 17/Apr/10
nick ferro - 2nd O/S - 17/Apr/10 with Jonathan Aylwin
wolverine - Lead O/S - 11/Apr/10 with Kate Bush
Did the crux then go a bit spooked and escaped off right. Have onsighted this previously...
Hardonicus - Lead dnf - 10/Oct/09
Hidden - 16/Jun/09
Hidden - 2nd O/S - 16/Jun/09
thomasadixon - Lead O/S - 29/Apr/09 with Lisa
Wouldn't have liked to lead this one! Really awkward move with quite poor gear! Only way I could figure of doing it, was using the poor flake, getting my right foot up onto the top of a small niche on the right, leftfoot on a poor smear, right foot up further on pretty much nothing, then a bit of a hop up to the top! Eep!
Reaver2k - 2nd O/S - 29/Apr/09 with Michael, Lisa, Tom and Andy
This was really good, hard for the short.
SGD - Lead O/S - 26/Apr/09 with Jenny Upright
richw2k2 - 2nd - 26/Apr/09 with Al
towdman - 2nd - 11/Jun/08 with Graham Armitage
Graham Armitage - Lead - 11/Jun/08 with towdman
towdman - Lead O/S - 04/Jun/08 with Sue Armitage
Hidden - Lead O/S - 01/Dec/07
John Kettle - 12/Aug/07
Hidden - Lead - 11/Aug/07
NeilManley - Lead O/S - Apr/05
adi bryant - Lead O/S - 2005