In reply to rj_townsend:
> So what? Still seems better than "you broke it, so your problem" to me, provided the "suitcase full of cash" is less than you'd be paying for a new unit.
So what? it might be the case that you want to keep the original because it was given to you as a present? or that you'd be pissed your week old broken iPad is replaced with a well used 11 month old one. Is there a possibility of your personal data being extracted by the new owner after its been factory reset?
Yes I agree Apple is very slick but so it should be for what it charges. A quick google shows a multitude of repairers that will do the same job for 300/400% less than Apple charges and from my experience the work is just as good.
You pays your money you take your choice.