In reply to Ramblin dave:
> Yeah, I do have that perspective. But that's also why I'm trying (honest!) to ask genuine questions rather than wade in assuming that my perspective is the right one...
>
How very reasonable of you! Can't ask for more than that.
> So I guess that what I'm trying to get at is what the basic issue is with the A82 from a local point of view. Does it regularly crap out because it's over capacity?
Yes, summer and bank holidays you can get standing jam from Tarbet souith to Balloch/Dumbarton. 45 mins+
>Is it the probability of getting stuck behind a coach indefinitely?
>
Yes, basically the road is almost incapable of taking buses or lorries in the north Loch Lomond section. It is literally lethal.
>Or is it just that it's slow because it's too bendy and too single-carriageway?
Yes, slow and dangerous. Not even asking for dual. But a single carriageway on which you can go faster than 30-40 and without risking your life with trucks and on-coming vehicles in the middle of the road.
> Tbf, no - I think of it as I would a road where I grew up in rural Kent or where I live in East Anglia and it just doesn't seem particularly worse than a lot of the roads I've spent a lot of time on in those areas.
>
Sigh, you're comparing the trunk road A82 with a rural road in Kent.
OK, will try and make my point better: fundamentally a lot of people make the mistake of equating Scotland with a small region of England (and I know that population wise we might be). So Scotland = Cumbria or East Anglia. I don't even think you realise you do this but I am pretty sure you mentally just parcel Scotland like this. Partially due to lack of familiarity with scope of Scotland. Even if you know the Highlands ok, you've probably skipped SW Scotland, Borders, lowland Perthshire, Angus, NE Scotland.
Whereas in fact Scotland = roughly 1/3 of UK land lass with some big distances complicated by (pleasingly) difficult terrain.
You've raised East Anglia and rural roads! But the A82 is a *trunk* road. It should be the as the A11 is to Norwich (although I am not asking for dual etc just a reasonable single carriageway A road!).
It just happens to go through some beautiful land on the way!