UKC

Bike mirrors - useful or the ultimate in uncool?

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
 AndyC 21 Jun 2012
Cars I can cope with but the antics of the 'Tour de Finance' peloton that seems to collect in my slipstream on the way home is making me seriously think about fitting a mirror.

Anybody tried using mirrors, or is it better to go out in a blaze of glory surrounded by twisted aluminium and mangled carbon fibre?
 tspoon1981 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: If you're worried about looking uncool, get these

http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B000NPGMHM/ref=redir_mdp_mobile

You'll be stylish and safe, you can also pretend to be a spy.
 Batcloud 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

Never used one until recently, just crossed Spain on a heavy/wobbly MTB and the mirror was indespensible, great safety aid.

The bar mounted compass was a godsend as well but one step at a time eh!
 Liam M 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: I'm confused what problem it would be solving. Do you not check behind you before making any change of line? Are other cyclists trying to cycle through you?
OP AndyC 21 Jun 2012
In reply to Liam M:
> (In reply to AndyC) I'm confused what problem it would be solving. Do you not check behind you before making any change of line? Are other cyclists trying to cycle through you?

99% of the time I know what's going on behind me, but sometimes you can't afford half a second to look back because you're doing 45 kph about 5 m from the car in front.

But an example from this afternoon - straight, flat, two lane road, I'm at the head of about 6 cyclists, approaching a long queue of stationary traffic at about 35 kph. Moved out close to the centre of the road and timed my pull out to overtake the queue with the passing of the last oncoming car. As I was crossing the centre line I found the guy behind had moved up so he was level with my pedal, leaving me almost nowhere to go. I didn't know he'd suddenly changed position because I was concentrating on the traffic ahead and I had assumed too much common sense in the folk behind.

If I'd had a mirror I might have seen what he was up to.



Talius Brute 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

Never tried a cycle mirror, but I agree with you re the cr@ppy tour de commuters that goes everywhere. I cycle 17 miles each way on my commute from west london into the city and apart from the odd car door from a mum dropping her kids off the real threat is other cyclists. For some reason it seems to be the slow ones who jump lights, push to the front at a junction when everyone has stopped, swerve randomly etc.
 tim000 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: if you were changing possition in the road you should always look behind .
 balmybaldwin 21 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

It sounds like you need to better indicate your intentions and maybe manoever a bit earlier to allow yourself the time to do a shoulder check, it could just as easily be a motor cyclist or the silent killer (prius running all electric).

However, if they are half wheeling you, give them some grief for it.
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to tim000:
> (In reply to AndyC) if you were changing possition in the road you should always look behind .

Thanks, I hadn't thought of that.
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to balmybaldwin:
> (In reply to AndyC)
>
> It sounds like you need to better indicate your intentions

I had safely moved into a position in the centre of the road where it was obvious where I was going to have to go next - down the outside of the line of cars or pile into the back of the queue. The guy behind seemed to assume I was planning the latter. If I hadn't made a final split-second check behind I would have taken him out.
 MJ 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

Do you use arm signals?
 Sir Chasm 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: I wouldn't bother, I've removed them from my car, now I just expect everybody to be a mindreader and know what I'm going to do without me signalling my intentions or even having a casual glance over my shoulder.
 cousin nick 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

No mirrors
See Rule #66
http://www.velominati.com/the-rules/
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to cousin nick:
> (In reply to AndyC)
>
> No mirrors
> See Rule #66
> http://www.velominati.com/the-rules/

Yeah! It was reading precisely that rule that prompted the question in the first place. But I give up on this thread, apart from one or two people (thanks Batcloud!) who bothered to read and answer the actual question, the rest is just the usual UKC wind-up.

For the record: yes - I use arm signals, yes - I always look behind before changing position, yes - I stop at red lights and pedestrian crossings, yes - I even give way to traffic on roundabouts.

NB: People who can't hear a Prius or a motorbike coming up behind probably shouldn't be on the road.

 paul-1970 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
Nothing uncool about the mirrors on this bike

http://www.keeleyhire.co.uk/images/items/full/1933.jpg
 digby 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

> but sometimes you can't afford half a second to look back because you're doing 45 kph about 5 m from the car in front.

!! Who needs protection from whom?!
Tim Chappell 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
>
sometimes you can't afford half a second to look back because you're doing 45 kph about 5 m from the car in front.
>


Hmm. Now I can think of another solution
 balmybaldwin 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
> (In reply to cousin nick)
> [...]
>
>
> yes - I always look behind before changing position,

So why did you say you didn't then?

KevinD 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

> Anybody tried using mirrors, or is it better to go out in a blaze of glory surrounded by twisted aluminium and mangled carbon fibre?

the ones i have seen have been bugger all use and if anything a liability since you might try using it rather than checking over shoulder.
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to balmybaldwin:
> (In reply to AndyC)
> [...]
>
> So why did you say you didn't then?

Because I apparently confused the issue by making a generalisation and then citing a specific event in the same post. In the latter a potential accident was avoided because I did a final look round and found a cyclist where I was definitely not expecting to see one.





OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to dissonance:
> (In reply to AndyC)
>
> [...]
>
> the ones i have seen have been bugger all use

Thanks! That's the kind of feedback I was after!
 tspoon1981 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
> (In reply to dissonance)
> [...]
>
> Thanks! That's the kind of feedback I was after!

Hey now, I gave you the stylish option.
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to tspoon1981:
> (In reply to AndyC)
> [...]
>
> Hey now, I gave you the stylish option.

That's true! A pair of those and that chopper bike and all my cycling problems would definitely be solved!
 tspoon1981 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: Treat yourself

http://ridelow.co.uk/
 paul-1970 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
You could 'phone a friend' and try out this solution to your problem:

http://tukortandem.uw.hu/_tukortandem/tukortandema091.jpg
 paul-1970 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:
You could also try this nifty and cool solution. This is what it looks like when in use:
http://0.tqn.com/d/bicycling/1/0/m/3/-/-/cycleaware_mirror.jpg

This is what the same device looks like when folded away:
http://www.zetaminor.com/images/dvd_review_images/carry_on/carry_again_char...
 Doug 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: Only just seen this thread. I used to have one & it was occassionally useful (especially for seeing something arriving behind) but had a limited field of vision so you still needed to look behind to be sure.

When that bike was stolen I never bothered to buy one for the 'new' bike (actually a hastily assembled bike based mostly on stuff lying around plus a few bought bits & pieces) or any bike I've owned since
 Tricky Dicky 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: I used to use a mirror when commuting along a busy A road, it was a mirricycle similar to this http://www.google.co.uk/products/catalog?q=mirrycle+mirror&rls=com.micr...

and it was the dogs danglies. You could just keep an eye on what was going on behind, then quick head turn to look behind, signal and manouver. My current commute is off-road, so I don't use one now, but if went back to busy road commuting I'd get another mirror straight away.
OP AndyC 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC:

Thanks everybody for the fableeous suggestions, a lot of good information there.

I'm heading out to play in the Friday afternoon traffic now... this may be my last post. Just remember - what you can't see, can't hurt you... or something like that.
 Voltemands 22 Jun 2012
In reply to AndyC: I use one of these -

Halfords Bike Eye Bike Mirror (UKC won't let me link)

Both absolutely useless and a great piece of kit.

Due to its location and size it just doesn't provide rapid/enough visibility to be usable intercity.

However, it's very subtle due to its location so you don't lose too many cool points and great for keeping track of riding partners bringing up the rear when on country roads. Unfortunately the girl friend is a bit slower than me (thank god i'm stronger than her at, at least one of our sports)so I used to find myself getting really far out in front and having to slow down so she could catch up, slightly frustrating cycle. With this little beauty I can see how far back she is and maintain a pace that suits her.

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Loading Notifications...