UKC

Primaloft Gold versus Tirol Wool Celliant?

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
 Si Withington 08 Jan 2019

Has anyone got the technical knowledge of insulation fill types to comment on 'how much warmer' Mountain Equipment's Fitzroy jacket is to Salewa's Ortles TirolWool Celliant jacket, or vice versa.

I need to make a decent comparison, for reasons I won't bore you with.

ME is: PrimaLoft® GOLD insulation (100g body and 80g arms/hood) 

Salewa fill is: TIROL WOOL® CELLIANT® 80 / TIROL WOOL® CELLIANT® 100 

https://www.mountain-equipment.co.uk/fitzroy-jacket

and

https://www.salewa.com/en-gb/shopware.php?sViewport=detail&sArticle=193...

Many thanks

Si

Post edited at 20:55
 Dave Cundy 09 Jan 2019
In reply to Si Withington:

I've just read the marketting blurb about Celliant.  As a former propulsion engineer, I think its full of unsubstantiated waffle.  In short, it sounds like "snake oil".

It talks about absorbing and reflecting infrared energy from the body.  But the manufacturing description suggested it is a fibre with low emissivity, so it's going to simply reflect body heat back towards the occupant. There's going to be little absorption going on.

And in any case, if your skin temperature is 30 degs C and the inner layer of the garment is at 25, i doubt there'll be much interchange of radiant heat.  It'll mostly be conduction and a bit of forced convection (caused by the occupant moving inside the garment).

Nowhere does it actually say how thick it is, or what it's thermal conductivity is.  But that would give the game away.

Caveat emptor...

 MischaHY 09 Jan 2019
In reply to Si Withington:

I'm going to go with 'Fecking ragingly warmer'. 

Hope this helps. 


New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Loading Notifications...