/ Vango gothic arches - strong or not?
I've been looking for a new car camping tent & quite like the look of some of the Vango ones. We use some 2015/2016 models at Scouts and they are pretty bombproof.
However, Vango now seem to have introduced a pointy ‘gothic arch’ into the poles, which looks to me to be a weak point in the curve. Does anybody have any experience of these poles and whether they are robust enough for 3 season use?
Got a cheap Vango tent as a emergency one, as my previous one has developed some leaks. Has the arch in the pole. Made me frown when I encountered it also. The overall quality of the of the tent is so dismal that I won't be buying Vango again.
Lightwave have/has some pointy arches on some of their lightweight tents. I'm sure they argued that they were stronger IIRC.
I have a Vango Spirit (the 2.5 man tent) of 2012 vintage which has the pointed shape. This is a really well made and robust tent, and I think the point may well be the strongest part of the pole. The point also works well with the diagonal tension straps because you can put more tension on without the pole bowing out.
The short kinked section does mean that the poles don't fold up quite as neatly.
In summary I think it improves the shape of the tent with minimal downsides.
NB the Spirit was ~£550 pounds worth of tent in 2012, so a different beast from the <£200 tents with this feature.
Fundamentally the Gothic Arch will be strong for the height, and never heard of any problems specific to this part of the poles (I was dealing with Vango in a previous job), and they've been using it for a good few years now.
Quality of the manufacture and materials used will probably be more important at the value end of the market.
I'd guess that for tents at that price point it introduces an unnecessary additional point of weakness.
Away from the mayhem of the Eastern Edges, the Roaches enjoys a unique atmosphere of its own. Amongst this mind-boggling cluster... Read more
Eliot Stephens has returned from a fantastic two week trip to Magic Wood where he climbed , a Bernd Zangerl 8B+. Eliot also... Read more
Berghaus has joined forces with an international expedition team as part of a women's product development initiative.... Read more
The Cirrus Flex is one of our most versatile jackets to date. Lightweight, warm, and breathable - this synthetic layer is... Read more