In reply to tmawer:
Hi Tony
A few of my mates that have tried it think its worth E5 as an onsight, because of the top section finishing up the wide easy gangway.
The trouble now?? is that most will mat out the landing (as I did), along with all of the other climbs. So maybe they should all be graded as modern highball boulder problems.
E7 might be a bit high for the others but they are 13m high so a slip off the top would do some damage!
After I had done Lenny Limpet, Scallop and Andy's Var finish I had a trip down to Froggatt Edge to climb on the slabs there to compare the grades.
I found that with Downhill Racer, Heartless Hare, Hairless Heart Great Slab etc they all have good(ish) holds, where if your foot was to pop etc you could still stay on, were as with the climbs on the Armathwaite slab a slip with any foot/hand you tend to fall off.
Technically the Armathwaite slab is easy (6a - 6b) but many of the holds are sandy and easy to slip from, making an onsight solo quite demanding and tenuous.
For what its worth I have seen 2 people hit the deck on Codpeice and know of 2 others also hitting the deck from half height so on the ukc page I have kept the E3 rating. Papermoon also has taken some scalps and at E3 is pretty serious E4/5 could easily be given.
Post edited at 13:52