In reply to TobyA:
> (In reply to captainfire576)
> [...]
>
> How long is a piece of string? What are you going to be doing in the winter alps? How high? Multi-day routes or valley ice cragging.
>
> I've got similar jackets to the Fitzroy, and sometimes for ice climbing in the Scandinavian winter they are great - all you need - and sometimes you'll get cold in them reasonably sharpish. It depends so massively on what you're doing, what the weather is like, what you're wearing underneath and how hard you are.
>
> If you're going out in temperatures of say -15 or -20 and its windy I suspect most people wouldn't stay warm in a mid warmth synth jacket like the Fitzroy, but it might work for you if you have other insulation below. I think no one can reasonably tell you "yes, it'll be fine" or "no, it won't" for all these factors.
>
> The DAS is virtually the same weight as the Fitzroy now, but I don't know if that means that it's not as warm as my heavier 12 year old one is.
Could not agree more, impossible question to answer really.
I tend to run hot so for me the Fitzroy is spot on even in the Alps, down to about -10, on multi pitch ice routes.It packs small, does not mind getting wet and does not vomit feathers if nicked by one of the many sharp bits on my harness, but if it gets colder, windier and there is a chance of more sitting still, then I lug my feather filled friend along!
Other tricks to consider is block leading and sharing clothing with your belayer. You will be amazed at what a difference a thin ish smock type mid layer can make when added to your mid weight synthetic belay jacket.