In reply to monkeyboy3000:
For your grades forget Rifle. The following would all be good and all are places I've climbed:
Red River Gorge. World Class and unique sandstone. This is where you will find the biggest jugs you'll ever fall off. Humid in spring and hot in summer. Late Sept into October is probably the best time, though I went in May and it was ok. Super fashionable place to climb - as it's just like juggy climbing wall stuff - and consequently often rammed at weekends.
New River Gorge a few hours away - bit more vertical and old school - including some of the bolting, but I loved it. Much quieter than the Red.
Ten Sleep Canyon in Wyoming has the best sport climbing in the US in my view. Ten Sleep is a beautiful unspoilt place and has absolutely loads to do at your grades on pocketed limestone. Very well bolted too. Great free camping and a good informal scene. Crazy unique guidebook.
Wild Iris and Sinks Canyon are nearby (by US standards) at Lander - which is cool outdoor/cowboy town. Similar limestone but generally shorter routes. Wind River ranges nearby for amazing hiking and alpine rock.
Between those 3 Wyoming areas you are looking thousands of sport routes. Possibly a bit cold for the next month but good for spring/summer.
Then you have Boulder Canyon and Clear Creek Canyon near Boulder Colorado with another 2000 routes of all grade and steepness. Maybe not absolutely world class, but very varied from slab to overhang on granite and granitic rock. It's warming up now so you can pick sunny side routes and climb then change to shady side in the summer. (Same for Tensleep). Camping is tricky nearby.
South Platte is a huge dispersed area with cool summer temperatures and a rapidly developing sport climbing scene on granite. Plenty of camping and no crowds.
3 hours further South there is Shelf Road near Canon City. More extensive pocket limestone like Ten Sleep but not quite as good in my opinion. Some love it. Sunny and climbed all year round. Lovely location with camping on site.
Further south Enchanted Tower in New Mexico is small but beautiful. Welded tuff with pockets sized from fingers to sit in and lie down. Possible year round.
Tucson AZ has Mount Lemmon on the doorstep and the awesome Cochise Stronghold about 2 hours away. Mt Lemmon is good but is traditionally a winter destination - baking in summer. Crap guidebook. Cochise is amazing but the best routes are all multi-pitch.
There is some nice Sport around Moab at Wall Street, Sunshine Wall and Ice Cream Parlour. Spring/fall best. Trad cracks at Indian Creek are the real destination climbing. But you have to go to Moab and other parts of S. Utah as it is the most beautiful place in the world.
Owens River Gorge near Bishop CA. is brilliant too but but only been once myself.
J Tree - I wasn't much taken with the place and not really a sport destination. Smith Rock - never been.
Finally, I met some people from Arkansas who reckon there is great sport there at Horseshoe Canyon Ranch.
I've scratched the surface, but you can't go wrong with that list. Mountain Project.com is great resource - and if you get the mobile app you can download areas and use it with no signal. This gets you to many areas and climbs then you can borrow a guide or buy one locally if you are going to be in the area for a few days. You'll find stuff on all these crags on MP.com.
PM me if you want any more info, though I may bang on about Ten Sleep..
