In reply to Chris Harris:
Understand the issue as I struggle terribly with hands when it's cold. Although of course it hasn't been an issue this year.
Pretty happy with a pair called Chiba. There is some neoprene on the back, but it has a leathery palm and soft inner fabric. Not waterproof but does have a nylon cover (lobster claw style) that folds away into a cuff. Haven't noticed any smelliness and easy to wash.
I like it because it has good grip, not bulky and I think a lot of the warmth comes from a high cuff that tucks under my jacket (I'm pretty convinced that a lot of keeping hands warms comes from keeping wrists insulated. Cheap too.
A lot of people swear by Castelli diluvios but I think these are mostly neoprene so probably get sweaty. I've never really liked the feeling of neoprene gloves (and the smell)
Friends seem to use sealskin too.