Piolets d'Or 2013 - Some Win, Some Resign

© Piolets d'Or
Last weekend saw the 2013 Piolets d'Or (Golden Ice Axe) ceremony in Chamonix (France) and Courmayeur (Italy). In an unprecedented move, all six of the nominated ascents were awarded an ice axe this year.

Amongst the six nominated ascents were two British teams, Mick Fowler and Paul Ramsden as well as Sandy Allan and Rick Allen (full nominee details here: UKC News).

The Piolets d'Or Award Ceremony 2013  © Piolets d'Or
The Piolets d'Or Award Ceremony 2013
© Piolets d'Or

The Piolets d'Or Award has had a rocky history, with many top level alpinists criticising the award back in 2007 spearheaded by Slovenian alpinist Marko Prezelj rejecting his nomination. This led to the awards being scrapped in 2008.

They came back in 2009 with a new ethos and things have been pretty rosy since then, with the ceremony being well received by most alpinists involved.

However with this year's award going to all the teams, it seems the Piolets d'Or committee are keen to be even more inclusive and not to single out an individual climb as being 'better' than the rest. But this is climbing, and of course some people aren't happy. By giving all the ascents a golden ice axe, some say the judges may have devalued the award itself.

Sandy Allan (Nanga Parbat); Sebastien Bohin (Kamet); Rick Allen (Nanga Parbat); Yasuhiro Hanatani and Tatsuya Aoki (Kyashar)   © Piolets d'Or
Sandy Allan (Nanga Parbat); Sebastien Bohin (Kamet); Rick Allen (Nanga Parbat); Yasuhiro Hanatani and Tatsuya Aoki (Kyashar)
© Piolets d'Or

The two founding organisations behind the Piolets d'Or are the Groupe de Haute Montagne (GHM) and also Editions Niveales the publishers behind Montagnes Magazine. Following this year's awards Manu Rivaud, the Editor in Chief for Montagnes Magazine, has resigned from the organisational committee, stating that Montagnes Magazine are "disappointed with the outcome which considerably weakens both the event and its stature".

Manu went on to comment at length on the Montagnes Magazine Website:

"How could providing the exact same award to the ascents of Nanga Parbat's Mazeno ridge and the Prow of Shiva not make the jury members feel even a little bit uneasy?

...Acting in this manner completely negates the notion of commitment, makes light of the problems inherently linked to climbing at high-altitude, and fails to recognize the innate human ability to innovate in challenging conditions. This decision blurs the benchmarks for future generations. In part, this act is a snub to who we are and to the history of mountaineering. All in all, it represents a total disregard for the art of climbing the highest summits in the world and for the artists who climb them, going as far as to make a mockery of each and every ascent nominated over the past twenty editions of the Piolets d'Or that did not win the award, an award that had set the standard until today."

His resignation follows that of Claude Gardien, the editor of Vertical Magazine, who resigned from his duties at the Piolets d'Or in March.

Whether Editions Niveales will pull out of the awards is as yet unannounced, and whether the awards could continue if they did is also unknown, however despite the petty politics of a few, it is undeniable that this last year has been a great year in the mountains, and the nominated ascents are a collection of outstanding achievements that we as climbers should be proud to celebrate.

Mountaineering will live on, with or without the current Piolets d'Or committee.

Our friends over at PlanetMountain have put together a collection of excellent short videos showcasing each of the nominated climbs. Watch, be inspired and go climbing!

Piolets d'Or Winners 2013:

Kyashar (6,770m), Nepal

Muztagh Tower (7,284m), Pakistan

Baintha Brakk (a.k.a The Ogre, 7,285m), Pakistan

Nanga Parbat (8,125m), Western Himalaya, Pakistan

Kamet (7,756m), India

Shiva (6,142m), India

This post has been read 9,390 times

Return to Latest News

Support UKC

As climbers we strive to make UKClimbing the kind of website we would love to visit, with the most up-to-date news, diverse and interesting articles, comprehensive gear reviews, breathtaking photographs and a vast and useful logbook system. As a result, an incredible community has formed around the site - we’ve provided the framework but it’s you who make the website what it is today. If you appreciate the content we offer then you can help us by becoming an official UKC Supporter. This can be a one-off single annual payment or a more substantial payment paid monthly or yearly which includes full access to Rockfax Digital and discounts on Rockfax print publications.

If you appreciate UKClimbing then please help us by becoming a UKC Supporter.

UKC Supporter

  • Support the website we all know and love
  • Access to a year's subscription to Rockfax Digital.
  • Plus 30% off Rockfax guidebooks
  • Plus Show your support UKC porter badge on your profile and forum posts
UKC/UKH/Rockfax logo

12 Apr, 2013
Just like what happened on Masterchef last year. It really annoys me - it's their job to pick a winner and what do they do? They shirk their duty. They need to stick their sodding necks out and choose...
12 Apr, 2013
Just to set the records straight, the Piolets d'Or was abandoned a few years ago because people felt that giving just a first prize was promoting competition and not in the spirt of alpinism. Since it has started up again there have been multiple prizes given out on the same year. More interestingly who would you have left out this year and not given an award too?
12 Apr, 2013
so...... You are annoyed that a team of rather proficient judges couldn't differentiate between 6 ascents that were cutting edge. It isn't dancing on ice or X factor. What's the difference between the 6. I would be glad to hear your opinion having a number of Himalayan/ alpine feats to your name.
12 Apr, 2013
also, what a surprise that the French editor chose to single out the British ascents. Why not say he kamet ascent v the mazeno ridge. Did mick and Paul not do the classic climbing thing of doing a route, getting home and not even bragging about it? If that isn't what the awards are about I don't know what is?
12 Apr, 2013
+1 mazeno ridge
More Comments
Loading Notifications...
Facebook Twitter Copy Email LinkedIn Pinterest