UKC

BMC Publish Report of the Independent Organisational Review Group

The findings of the BMC's Independent Organisational Review Group (ORG) were announced at Kendal Town Hall on Saturday 18th November. Amidst the hustle and bustle of Kendal Mountain Festival this was a major event for many, with the report and its findings - which had been conducted completely independently - being a total unknown to both staff and membership alike. Considering the wide reaching and all-encompassing nature of the review, there was certainly a lot of speculation and anticipation about what their recommendations were.

Rab Carrington (left) and ORG Chair Ray Wigglesworth (right) , 111 kb
Rab Carrington (left) and ORG Chair Ray Wigglesworth (right)
© Rob Greenwood - UKC

The ORG was setup to "look at the way the BMC currently works – in terms of organisation, governance, and decision-making structures – and evaluate how this reflects current best practice in governance, whilst continuing to act in the best interests of the membership. The group will also recommend new ways to increase engagement and consultation with all BMC members on key issues".

Their findings come in two formats, the first (and more accessible) is a 20 page summary and the second (and more detailed) is the 40 page document, both can be found by clicking on the relevant reports below. Those short on time may prefer the one page summary of the key themes of the recommendations, plus the chart of the chart outlining the recommended organisational structure of the BMC, both of which are included beneath the two papers.

The Organisational Review Summary Report, 29 kb

Organisational Review Full Report, 29 kb

Key Themes, 117 kb

ORG Chart, 95 kb

What happens next?

Local Area meetings are an opportunity to hear about the detail of the ORG report and ask questions (dates + venues outlined at the base of this article). The BMC's independent ORG understands that there's a huge amount of detail in the report, so you don't have to make any votes or decisions right away: this is just the start of the consultation period.

There'll be a member consultation survey launching this week, and emailed to all members, where individuals can express support or opposition to the recommendations and comment on specific sections. This will be run by 2020 Research, an independent market research company. This consultation will run until 22nd December.

Throughout the next month there'll also be Q&As, focus groups, and requests for written feedback. The ORG will present and take questions from National Council in early December. After Christmas the ORG review all the feedback gathered and look to make any changes, and add details to the recommendations where the ORG needs to, as well as to draft a new set of Articles of Association. After that there'll be another round of Local Area Meetings in late January, and a National Council Meeting in early February.

Anything the ORG proposes that requires changes to the Memorandum & Articles of Association (M&AA) will require the approval of 75% of those voting members present and attending (in person or by proxy) an AGM, and voting in favour, in order to be accepted. The BMC AGM is currently planned for the end of April.

Recommendations that don't require M&AA changes can be dealt with in other ways, again, potentially a vote at AGM. How that's dealt with will be able to be more detailed once initial feedback from the consultation is gathered.

The member consultation survey is available here.

North West
Date: Monday 20 November 2017, starting at 7.30pm (food from 7.00pm)
Venue: The Anderton Centre, New Road, Anderton, Chorley PR6 9HG
ORG presentation by: Rab Carrington and Ray Wigglesworth

Cymru South Wales
Date: Tuesday 21 November 2017, starting at 7.30pm (food from 7.00pm)
Venue: Up and Under, 490 Cowbridge Road East, Cardiff CF5 1BL
ORG presentation by: Fiona Sanders and Rebecca Ting

Cymru North Wales
Date: Wednesday 22 November 2017, starting at 7.00pm (food from 6.30pm)
Venue: Plas y Brenin, Capel Curig LL24 0ET
ORG presentation by: Rab Carrington and Rebecca Ting
Find out more on the BMC Local Areas site

Midlands
Date: Wednesday 22 November 2017, starting at 8.00pm
Venue: Old Edwardians Sports Club, Streetsbrook Road, Solihull B90 3PE
ORG presentation by: Fiona Sanders and Tim Strong

Peak
Date: Wednesday 22 November 2017, starting at 6.30pm (food from 6.00pm)
Venue: The Maynard, Main Road, Grindleford S32 2HE
ORG presentation by: John Roberts and Ray Wigglesworth

London & South East
Date: Thursday 23 November 2017, starting at 7.00pm
Venue: The Old King's Head, 45-49 Borough High St, London SE1 1NA
ORG presentation by: John Roberts and Matthew Bradbury

South West
Date: Saturday 25 November 2017, starting at 7.00pm
Venue: The Nova Scotia Hotel, Nova Scotia Place, Bristol BS1 6XJ
ORG presentation by: Fiona Sanders and Simon McCalla

Yorkshire
Date: Monday 27 November 2017, starting at 7.00pm
Venue: The Wheatley Arms, Wheatley Lane, Ben Rhydding LS29 8PP
ORG presentation by: Fiona Sanders and Rab Carrington

Lakes
Date: Wednesday 29 November 2017, starting at 7.30pm
Venue: Hawkshead Brewery, Mill Yard, Staveley LA8 9LR
ORG presentation by: John Roberts and Ray Wigglesworth

North East
Date: Thursday 30 November 2017, starting at 7.00pm
Venue: Honest Lawyer Hotel, Croxdale Bridge, Durham DH1 3SP
ORG presentation by: Fiona Sanders and Ray Wigglesworth
NOTE: change of venue, originally advertised as taking place at Durham Climbing Centre


Forums (73 comments)

Well, having read the report and attended a presentation at the local area meeting (SW), it all seems very sensible and the way forward. There are things which could be changed slightly and now we have a consultation...
My understanding is that the issue of primacy which I think is what is being referred to, together with the other changes to the Memorandum and Articles of Association (MAA) has to go to the AGM and get 75% of the votes...
Hi Paul, Well if the final vote is 'for' the new structure then they're out of the firing line :-) Whoops. 'We're' out of the firing line. If the vote goes against, or there is a delay in implementation then it's just...
Hi Rupert, Hope you had a good summer after the travails of the AGM? Whilst I, obviously, tremble at the idea of jousting with you over legality :-) I am gratified that you seem to accept my suggestion that the BMC is...
It's because the phrases "illegal" and "in breach of" don't really apply here. The CA 2006 says that the directors of the company (which in the BMC's case is the exec) are "deemed" to have...
I'm not an expert in these matters but they seem to have got it sorted in skiing with the Skiclub GB representing recreational skiers and the British Ski+Snowboard representing competitors and being the NGB. So why...

Read more

This has been read 4,750 times