UKC

Supported by

Full size version is only available to registered users


Please Register as a New User or Login as Existing User to gain full access to all the photos on this site. Registration is quick and completely free.
Unregistered users can only view full size photos that have been added this month.

thumb
John Stainforth completing Holly Tree Wall (VS), Cwm Idwal, in big boots and carrying a sack.
© Gordon Stainforth, Apr 1969
Route: Original Route (VS 5a)
Camera used: Cheap plastic Kodak ??
Date taken: 4th April 1969
Supported by
VOTING: from 6 votes
Login as Existing User
to rate this photo.

User Comments

We did an integral route of Charity, HTW, Upper Staircase, Abraham's Crack and Senior's Ridge
Gordon Stainforth - 02/Feb/07
... wearing mountain boots and sacks as training for forthcoming Norwegian trip.
Gordon Stainforth - 11/May/07
Hello Gordon,
Was it really VS - 5a in 1969 ? In my day it was Hard Severe and certainly a challenge.
Scotty Dwyer fell off it guiding on about his sixtieth ascent, went back up and completed it but never did the climb again.
It reminds me of Barry Brewster who used to say that the graded list of climbs should be : HS, VS, HVS, Extreme and "Ogwen Hard Severe" !
Regards,
Boje
PS - Obviously I am browsing through your gallery, which is excellent, so I thought I would add a few comments.
Removed User - 17/Jan/15
Well, no, technical grades didn't exist then. The delightful Tony Moulam 'Cwm Idwal' guidebook we were using then said:
'Original Route. 130 feet. Very Severe. A fine rock-climb, that of the Wall. Generally ledges are small and the exposure of the route therefore may seem high, but the technicalities are not great. Even the first pitch depends rather on a trick.'
Those were the days when they knew how to write guidebooks ;)
Gordon Stainforth - 17/Jan/15
Just to clarify further. Our Moulam 'Cwm Idwal' guide dated from 1964, and it was graded Very Severe then. Indeed, I thought one of the historical points about it was that it was a very early and remarkable VS dating from 1918. In 1969 the crux move on the first pitch was widely regarded as 5a, and all subsequent guidebooks have confirmed that.
Gordon Stainforth - 20/Jul/18
Login as Existing User to add your comments
This picture is copyright. If you want to reproduce or otherwise re-use it, please email the photographer direct via their user profile. Photo added February 02 2007.
Loading Notifications...