u got a 4 from me but too much sky in the pic and it may work as a horizontal view, just my worthless opinion , nice pic though

I thought lemming ridge was the one on your right as you descend north off the plateau, but this doesnt look like it. which one is this? cheers, Jon.

I think the amount of sky's OK (about follows rule of thirds, would look unbalanced otherwise..) but the horizon looks tilted to me - hard to be sure of course, I wasn't there!). What I would say is that if you could set the lightest and darkest points to nearer true white and black (using levels or curves if you have them) then the whole thing would have more punch..
Cheers
Paul

I have replaced the original portrait photo with another landscape photo of the same view.