Loading Notifications...

Bans are not the Answer to Wild Camping Problems Opinion

© Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park

Across Britain's national parks and upland areas, informal roadside camping has become a hot topic in recent months - and for all the wrong reasons. Well-publicised issues with litter, human waste, wildfires and antisocial behaviour are leading some to call for a legislative solution - even in Scotland, where liberal access laws currently permit free camping if carried out responsibly.

In an article first published in the Inverness Courier, Mountaineering Scotland's CEO Stuart Younie suggests a more collaborative response.


People have been enjoying the experience of wild camping in Scotland for many years, right back to when it was just called camping and tents were made from canvas rather than hi-tech fabrics. The equipment may have changed with the years, but the pleasures of sleeping 'under canvas' and waking to the sights and sounds of the countryside, and the bracing fresh air, have never faded.

Pressures on the countryside are at an all-time high and we must all work together to make sure we find solutions that are to everyone's benefit

But like so many of the outdoor community and those who live in rural areas, I have been appalled and daunted by the image camping has acquired in these last weeks, as staycationers have flocked in insupportable numbers to so many of our cherished beauty spots, leaving litter, human waste and even whole abandoned campsites in their wake – not to mention the problem of poorly managed campfires and the damage and danger they cause.

It's not hard to understand – or even sympathise with – residents who call for camping bans or strict regulation.

But when you look into what's happening, there are already existing laws which cover the damage, the littering, the careless disposal of waste and the burning. The problem is the lack of resources to persuade people to respect these laws or to enforce them.

New legislation will take time and money to devise and implement and will face the same difficulty in enforcement – as well as criminalising the behaviour of considerate campers; the 'invisible' majority who pass lightly and leave no trace beyond some temporarily flattened grass.

Abandoned camp site at Loch Chon  © Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park
Abandoned camp site at Loch Chon
© Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park

The problem can't be ignored though, and it's hugely encouraging to see so many different people and organisations speaking to one another to discuss solutions and working together to implement them.

Education must play a major role. Mountaineering Scotland has been taking a twin-pronged approach, with a Considerate Camping campaign which advises people about best practice for informal camping, be that wild or roadside, and also a relaunch of our Tak It Hame campaign, which encourages people to take home any rubbish they find as well as their own.

Both are built on the terms of the Scottish Outdoor Access Code and generations of experience in all types of camping and outdoor living. We have not only been targeting our own members with these campaigns but trying to share them as widely as possible amongst new campers too.

As it should be - a low impact camp in the Cairngorms...  © Neil Reid
As it should be - a low impact camp in the Cairngorms...
© Neil Reid

...Leaving no trace but a little square of flattened grass  © Neil Reid
...Leaving no trace but a little square of flattened grass
© Neil Reid

In an ideal world, everyone should at least know about the Scottish Outdoor Access Code (SOAC) and that they have responsibilities as well as rights. But the experience of many countryside rangers has been that so often when they approach so-called 'dirty campers', the problem has been ignorance rather than 'badness'.

People aren't born knowing that green wood doesn't burn but the dirt (peat) under their fire might. They may well know it's not right to do their toilet behind that bush at the side of someone's garden, but don't know and are too embarrassed to ask what they should do.

That's not to make excuses: some examples of dirty camping – particularly littering and abandoning tents etc – are so blatant that mere ignorance of SOAC doesn't even nearly cover it.

But if you can reach someone and help them understand why it's so important to care for our countryside – and how they can do that – then you are potentially making another teacher who can, in turn, persuade others to love our wild places responsibly and to enjoy visiting them considerately. Caring for the countryside becomes a matter of social conformity rather than a diktat from on high.

Of course nothing happens in a vacuum, and it is heartening to see Highland Council and Perth and Kinross Council both working on measures to tackle the issue.

This has included taking a multi-agency approach, working with Police Scotland and local communities, as well as looking to improve facilities for tourism, including everything from temporary toilet facilities to expanded countryside ranger services, increased waste collection and improved traffic management.

At this time when the health benefits of the great outdoors have never been clearer, and when in this pandemic-hit world we are being encouraged by the Scottish Government to 'staycation', pressures on the countryside are at an all-time high and we must all work together to make sure we find solutions that are to everyone's benefit, providing a better quality of visitor experience and protecting the countryside we all love.

  • For more camping advice see:



Support UKC

We need your help.

UKClimbing is a vibrant web site with rich content and an amazing community. So far, all we've asked of you is that you visit and interact with the site but we are in uncertain times. We need to look at ways to keep the site moving forward whilst maintaining our key aim of allowing free access to everyone to our main content. The site will continue to be mainly funded by a subtle level of outdoor-only advertising but we now need extra support to ensure we can continue to provide the UKC that we all know and love.

You can help us by becoming a UKC Supporter. This can be in a small way or in a larger package that includes discounted products from our sister-publishing company Rockfax.

If you appreciate UKClimbing then please help us by becoming a UKC Supporter.

UKC Supporter

  • Support the website we all know and love
  • Access to a year's subscription to Rockfax Digital.
  • 30% off Rockfax guidebooks
  • Show your support UKC Supporter badge on your profile and forum posts

If when you go wild camping you pitch late, pack up early and leave no trace; if you bury your shit and burn your bog roll instead of leaving it on a belay ledge; if you park in a designated car park instead of on a path blocking wheelchair access - ask yourself why you do these things.

It's not, probably, because they're illegal or frowned upon by your peers - it's because you know that this behaviour is unacceptable. How do you know? It's because you've been educated to understand why it's unacceptable.

It's the same argument for any kind of antisocial behaviour. People don't, generally, refrain from murder and theft because they're afraid of the consequences. It's because they know that it's wrong.

18 Aug

Burning toilet roll is a poor choice though as it has a significant risk of starting wild fires.

Fair point, though it would only be a risk in the same circumstances that, say, using a camping stove would be a risk. In which case I would expect people to use sensible judgement.

18 Aug

I'd class murder as slightly more than antisocial.

People definitely stick to speed limits more if they think they'll be caught.

18 Aug

I think education can only go so far. I remember being on a night out shortly after starting university. On the walk back to the halls of residence we stopped for burger, eating it as we carried on home. One of the lads, from a rough west Cumbrian town, dropped the burger box as soon as he had finished.

When challenged by the rest of us why he didn't use a bin he simply replied "I'm finished with it". There was zero comprehension or recognition that it might be anti social. Needless to say the rest of the group were not impressed and at a loss as to why he didn't use one of the many bins en route.

Sadly I see many of the problem campers as having the same ignorant as pigsh*t attitude.

More Comments

Facebook Twitter Copy Email LinkedIn Pinterest