In reply to paul mitchell:
Unlike Keanu Reeves, I can't tell you what the truth is, but I can take a view on depression. I think there's a whole mix of things that we call 'depression' from a mental illness that's best treated with drugs, to something that I'd call 'misery' or 'shit life syndrome' and a big mixture in between.
When I think it's best viewed as a mental illness is when looked at objectively, the facts of the matter just aren't that bad and the person's emotional experience of their situation seems from outside to be inappropriate. I've met plenty of people who have loads of talent and opportunity that others would kill for, they're not trapped into any bad situation, they have people who love them (and there's no practical barriers to meeting more): their future is bright, and yet, they feel worthless and want to kill themselves.
On the other hand, I've met people who've made a massive pig's breakfast of their life, they've got every reason to feel terrible because they're trapped in an awful situation and they don't appear to possess the wherewithal to turn things around. As far as I'm concerned it's a moot point as to whether this is 'their fault' or not - it's the way it is. They might be 'depressed' by a medical definition, but really the problem is that their life has gone to shit and that makes them feel bad.
Of course these are two extremes on a scale - often what's termed 'depression' is an interplay of externally and internally generated misery. And how's best to try to mitigate that misery is going to depend enormously on what's causing it. It certainly isn't simply in the control of the depressed person to 'think positively' or 'take action to improve their situation' - if it was that easy, they'd just have done it ages ago.
If I was to try to finish the sentence "Truth is, you don't struggle with depression..." I'd say, "well maybe you do, but if actually it's shit life syndrome, then calling it depression probably isn't very helpful...but if it is basically a mental illness then you'd probably be best using medications and CBT...either way, accept any help going that's likely to lead to improvement of your mental state". Which probably wouldn't fly as an internet meme, especially as I'm not a Hollywood actor with pretensions of philosophical wisdom.
Post edited at 23:22